This 9-minute video, showing Israeli Jewish
MPs’ reaction to a speech by Haneen Zoabi today,
offers a very revealing insight into how Israel’s
tribal democracy works. And it isn’t pretty.
Even in the British parliament, which is
imploding at the moment, it is impossible to imagine
scenes like these.
Zoabi made the speech after Israel agreed this
week very belatedly to pay compensation to the
families of nine humanitarian activists killed by
Israeli commandos in 2010 on the Mavi Marmara, as it
plied international waters on its way to deliver aid
to Gaza. In fact, it would be more accurate to
say Israel assassinated the activists, as a way to
deter others from following in their wake.
The Marmara was a Turkish vessel and the
compensation was part of Israel’s reconciliation
deal with Turkey.
Zoabi was the only Israeli MP on the ship, and
was accused of treason by Knesset members for
participating in the aid flotilla. She became public
enemy number one and received many death threats at
the time, including some barely veiled ones from
Jewish MPs.
All the exchanges in this video are in Hebrew,
but that doesn’t really matter. You don’t need to
understand the language to understand what is going
on. One Jewish MP, Oren Hazan, of Netanyahu’s Likud
party, heckles Zoabi non-stop for more than four
minutes, with the Speaker doing nothing more than
politely asking him to calm down and refrain from
interrupting.
Remember that Palestinians MPs are regularly
ejected from the Knesset for far less than this kind
of barracking and violation of parliamentary
protocol. Notice also that the Knesset TV spends as
much time, if not more, focusing on the heckler than
Zoabi, implicitly legitimising his anti-democratic
behaviour.
But when Zoabi accuses the soldiers of “murder”
at about 4.30-min into the video, all hell breaks
loose. A dozen or more Jewish MPs rush to the podium
and start circling Zoabi like a pack of baying
hyenas. By this stage, when Zoabi is being
physically threatened by a number of MPs in the
parliament chamber, you might think it would be time
for some of them to be forcefully ejected, if only
to indicate that this subversion of the democratic
process will not be tolerated. But not a bit of it.
They are treated with kid gloves.
The Knesset guards simply try to block the
violent Jewish MPs from reaching the single
Palestinian MP in their sights, presumably fearful
that were she to be physically assaulted that might
make headline news and make Israel look bad.
Paradoxically, the only MP you can see on the
film being pushed out of the Knesset chamber is
Zoabi’s party leader, Jamal Zahalka, who from the
look of things is interceding because he’s worried
she is in danger. Hazan was finally removed, though
after more than eight minutes of heckling, threats
and belligerence.
Another paradox: Zoabi and her fellow party MPs
have only recently been allowed to speak in the
Knesset again, after the ethics committee (dominated
by Jewish MPs) suspended them for several months
because of their “unacceptable” political views.
I doubt very much that any of these Jewish MPs,
even though they have threatened and tried to
physically harm another MP, one from the wrong
tribe, will suffer any consequences at all for their
behaviour.
Zoabi said
in her speech: “I stood here six years ago, some
of you remember the hatred and hostility toward me,
and look where we got to. Apologies to the families
of those who were called terrorists. The nine that
were killed, it turns out that their families need
to be compensated. I demand an apology to all the
political activists who were on the Marmara and an
apology to MK Haneen Zoabi, who you’ve incited
against for six years. I demand compensation and I
will donate it to the next flotilla. As long as
there’s a siege, more flotillas need to be
organized.”
In addition to the violent reception from MPs
visible on film, there was widespread incitement
from other MPs. Michael Oren, who a while back was
Israel’s ambassador to the US, sounded like Avigdor
Lieberman as he said Zoabi’s speech proved she was
not loyal and should be permanently stripped of her
parliamentary status, under a soon-to-be-passed
Suspension Law.
In true colonial style, the government’s chief
whip, David Bitan, was reported to have told
Palestinian voters in Israel after Zoabi’s speech:
“We need to make sure she doesn’t stay in the
Knesset. We’ve had enough of this and she doesn’t
even represent you properly.”
Jonathan
Cook is a Nazareth- based journalist and winner of
the Martha Gellhorn Special Prize for Journalism
Netanyahu ‘to work toward
ousting Arab Knesset member’:
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says he
plans to work toward ousting an Arab member of the
Israeli parliament (Knesset) who has described the
Israeli commandos who killed ten Turkish activists
back in 2010 as “murderers.”
It is unacceptable to slander, smear or engage in personal attacks on authors of articles posted on ICH.
Those engaging in that behavior will be banned from the comment section.
In accordance
with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material
is distributed without profit to those who have
expressed a prior interest in receiving the
included information for research and educational
purposes. Information Clearing House has no
affiliation whatsoever with the originator of
this article nor is Information ClearingHouse
endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)