Barak Flogs
Netanyahu, Laments ‘Budding Fascism’ In Israel
Former PM accuses premier of lying about his desire
for Palestinian statehood, cheapening the Holocaust
by ‘Hitlerizing’ every threat
By Judah Ari Gross
June 18, 2016
"Information
Clearing House"
- "Times
Of Israel"
-
Former prime
minister Ehud Barak blasted Israel’s current
government on Thursday evening, saying it was
putting the country on the path to becoming an
“apartheid state,” and should be brought down if it
fails to get back on track.
“I call on the
government to come to its senses, to get back on
track immediately,” said Barak. “If it does not do
that, it will be incumbent upon all of us — yes, all
of us — to get up from our seats, comfortable ones
and uncomfortable ones, and bring it down via
popular protest and via the ballot box before it’s
too late,” he said.
Calling the
Netanyahu government “weak, flaccid and noisy,”
Barak lobbed criticism after criticism at the
Israeli leader and his ministers in a blistering
speech at the Herzliya Conference, accusing them of
operating based on a “covert agenda” to make a
two-state solution untenable.
“Fulfilling
[that agenda] will inevitably — and that’s a key
word in this discussion: inevitably — bring us to a
single state, which will be an apartheid state,”
Barak said. “Or it will be a bi-national state with
a Jewish minority in a generation or two — which
will have a high likelihood of experiencing a
drawn-out civil war.”
He also said
Israel faces “no existential threats” from regional
enemies, and accused Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu of magnifying the threats from terror
groups and other enemies by comparing them all to
Nazi Germany. “Hitlerization by the prime minister
cheapens the Holocaust,” he said. “Our situation is
grave even without [comparisons to] Hitler.”
Netanyahu
dismissed the criticisms, accusing Barak of
attacking him “once a month” in a bid to “stay
relevant.”
Barak, who
last served as defense minister under Netanyahu
until 2013 when he quit politics, echoed comments
made earlier in the day by another former defense
minister, Moshe Ya’alon, saying Israel’s government
and the Likud had been taken over by a “fanatical
core group with a radical ideology” that freely
attacks the Supreme Court, the freedom of expression
and other principles of democracy.
“Only a blind
person or a sheep, an ignoramus or someone jaded,
can’t see the erosion of democracy and the ‘budding
fascism,'” Barak said, to considerable applause from
the audience.
Referencing
the controversy surrounding statements made last
month by IDF Deputy Chief of Staff Yair Golan, who
seemingly drew parallels between Israel and Nazi
Germany, Barak made it clear that he was not
comparing Israel to the European fascism of “90
years ago — not 70 years ago.”
“But if it
looks like budding fascism, walks like budding
fascism and quacks like budding fascism, that’s the
situation,” he said, to another round of applause.
The ‘covert agenda’
After the end
of his tenure as defense minister in 2013 when
elections were called by Netanyahu, Barak said, he
“thought, naively, that this was a government that
didn’t know where it was going, but many of my best
friends in the world suspect that Netanyahu’s
administration knows quite well what it wants. There
is a covert plan,” Barak accused.
“What is this
agenda?” he asked rhetorically, before launching
into a lengthy, numbered answer.
“One, Israel
plans to continue controlling the area that was
conquered, liberated in 1967 forever. Two, Israel is
not interested in two states, and doesn’t want a
Palestinian state right next door. Three, Israel is
waiting for the world to adapt to and accept this
reality, and is hoping that tough incidents — like
terror attacks in Europe, the situation in Syria,
and so on — will divert its attention [from the
situation here],” Barak said.
“Four, Israel
will agree to autonomy with limited rights for
Palestinians, but not a state. Five, Israel will
continue carefully building in the settlements and
beyond them in order to gradually create
irreversible facts on the ground,” he added.
To counteract
those alleged actions, the former prime minister
called for renewed ties with the Palestinian
Authority, which he said was the only thing keeping
Hamas, the Islamic State and other dangerous terror
groups out of the West Bank. Netanyahu, he claimed,
was in fact bringing “Hamas and the Islamic State
closer to Jerusalem and Kfar Saba,” a suburb of Tel
Aviv.
Responding to
recent statements by the prime minister and defense
minister embracing the possibility of a peace
agreement with the Palestinians, Barak called
Netanyahu disingenuous — and blatantly so.
“In capitals
around the world — in London and Washington, in
Berlin and Paris, in Moscow and Beijing — no leader
believes a word coming out of Netanyahu’s mouth or
his government’s,” he said.
Going forward,
he encouraged Israel to seriously revisit the Arab
Peace Initiative, which he called “not ideal,” but a
“basis for negotiations.”
Israel, Barak
said, was rapidly approaching a fork in the road,
one way leading to all-out war with the
Palestinians, and the other leading to an apartheid
state.
“We are at the
start of the path, whose inevitable end is similar
to Belfast and Bosnia or old Johannesburg, and even
all three together,” he said.
That situation
would lead to a break between Israel and other
countries around the world, as well as a
deterioration in the relationship between Israel and
Jewish communities in America.
“They will
only accept a single state if — and only if — it’s a
Jewish-Arab nation of all its citizens, operating on
the condition of ‘one person, one vote’ — and who
among us wants that?” he asked.
Where do we go from here?
Aside from the
issue of the Palestinians, Barak blamed the
government for failing to plan for the future and
handle the problems currently facing Israel.
Those issues
included “the cost of living, the cost of
apartments, the weakening of the middle class, the
injustice in the deep wage gap,” he said, neglecting
to mention his own impressive personal wealth.
Israel, Barak
said, is generally doing well.
“Go to the
periphery, to units in the IDF, to the colleges and
you will find a more patriotic Israel, one that is
proud, optimistic and confident than what the media
would have you think,” he said.
But, the
former prime minister said, again echoing Ya’alon,
“Israel needs a different leadership, one that has a
compass and not a weather vane, one that has the
Declaration of Independence in its backpack, and not
— God forbid — ‘Torat HaMelech.'” He was referring
to a radical piece of religious literature favored
by Jewish extremists.
It was not
clear whether Barak’s fiery speech signaled a
possible return to the political fold. Asked by The
Times of Israel if he intended to return to
politics, Barak responded: “Let’s just leave it at
what I said in there for now.” |