America in
the 21st Century
Reports document growing income inequality,
declining manufacturing pay
By Kate Randall
May 15,
2016 "Information
Clearing House"
- "WSWS"
- A
new study from the Pew Research Center shows that
more than four-fifths of US metropolitan areas have
seen household incomes decline in the new century.
The research is based on data from urban centers
that are home to three-quarters of the US
population.
Pew’s
America’s Shrinking Middle Class shows that
middle-class household income has declined
throughout the population, while at the same time
the gap between low- and upper-income households has
grown, demonstrating a significant increase in
income inequality across the US. A major contributor
to economic decline and inequality has been the
plunge in manufacturing jobs and wages.
The study
analyzed data from 229 of the 381 metropolitan areas
in the US, as defined by the Office of Management
and Budget (OMB). These areas accounted for 76
percent of the US population in 2014. They included
all those that could be identified in US Census
Bureau data with statistics available for both 2000
and 2014.
Middle-income households are defined as those with
incomes of about $42,000 to $125,000, adjusted for a
household of three. Pew found that the share of
middle-income households fell in 203 of 299
metropolitan areas from 2000 to 2014. With household
income falling in the middle-income tier in these
areas, the shares of upper- and lower-income tiers
have correspondingly grown.
Based on US
Census figures, the share of middle-income adults
also fell nationwide, while the shares in the lower-
and upper-income tiers have increased. The national
share of middle-income adults decreased from 55
percent in 2000 to 51 percent in 2014. At the other
poles of society, the share of adults in the
upper-income tier increased from 17 percent to 20
percent, and the share of adults in the lower-income
tier increased from 28 percent to 29 percent.
US
metropolitan areas with the lowest household incomes
are mainly located in the South. Areas with the
highest household incomes are concentrated along the
Northeast corridor and mid-Atlantic, from Boston to
the District of Columbia, and in Northern
California, representing the proliferation and
profits of the tech, insurance and finance
industries, as well as high-paid government
employees and politicians.
Midland,
Texas, which benefited from the rise in oil prices
from 2000 to 2014, saw both a shrinking middle
class, which fell from 53 percent to 43 percent, and
a decline in lower income households, falling from
28 percent to 21 percent. The recent drop in oil
prices is not reflected in these figures.
In nearly
half of the metropolitan areas studied, the
lower-income share of households increased. The 10
metropolitan areas with the greatest losses in
overall economic status—the change in the share of
upper-income adults minus the change in the share
who were lower-income—have one thing in common: a
greater than average reliance on manufacturing.
These
include the Rust Belt areas of Springfield, Ohio and
Detroit-Warren-Dearborn, Michigan, as well as two
North Carolina areas: Rocky Mount and
Hickory-Lenoir-Morgantown.
In
Springfield, which saw the biggest decline in
economic status, a 16 percent drop, the truck
assembly plant owned by Navistar employs thousands
fewer workers than it did in its heyday.
The Detroit
metropolitan area has seen a dramatic decline in
auto jobs, as well as a drastic drop in wages
through two-tier systems introduced in large part as
a result of the Obama administration’s auto bailout,
carried out with the collaboration of the United
Autoworkers union.
The
Hickory-Lenoir-Morgantown area, once a thriving
center of furniture manufacturing, has seen the
demise of this industry, with an accompanying
decline in household incomes and an increase in
poverty.
A brief
from the UC Berkeley Labor Center documents the
impact on incomes of declining manufacturing wages
and the proliferation of temporary staffing
agencies.
Producing Poverty: The Public Cost of Low-Wage
Production Jobs in Manufacturing charts the
increasing numbers of manufacturing workers who are
forced to rely on government programs, such as
Medicaid and food stamps, to survive.
The study
shows that wages in manufacturing are falling to the
levels of those in the fast-food industry and at
big-box retailers. In 2013, the typical
manufacturing production worker made 7.7 percent
below the median wage for all occupations. The
median wage of these production workers was $15.66,
with a quarter making $11.91 or less.
The
National Employment Law Project (NELP) also found
that since 1989 there has been a significant
increase in the hiring of frontline production
workers through temporary staffing agencies.
Frontline workers are defined as non-supervisorial
production workers who work at least 27 hours per
week in the manufacturing industry or those closely
associated with it.
The
Berkeley study found that high utilization of
government programs by manufacturing workers was
primarily due to low wages as opposed to inadequate
work hours. Economic Policy Institute researchers
found that as manufacturing wages have declined,
manufacturing labor productivity has grown by an
average of 3.3 percent a year from 1997 to 2012,
nearly one-third greater than in the private,
nonfarm economy as a whole.
This means
that the manufacturing industry is sucking more and
more productivity out of workers while catapulting
them out of the “middle class” and into poverty
through low wages.
There has
been a dramatic growth in low-paying temporary
positions, which now account for 9 percent of
frontline manufacturing jobs—a nine-fold increase
from 25 years ago. Temporary workers earn a median
wage of $10.88 an hour, compared to $15.03 for those
hired directly by manufacturers.
Nearly half
of all manufacturing workers hired through staffing
agencies are enrolled in at least one public
assistance program, just below the 52 percent of
fast-food workers who rely on these programs.
Ken Jacobs,
chair of the Labor Center and co-author of the
report, told Berkeley News, “Manufacturing
has long been thought of as providing high-paying,
middle-class work, but the reality is the production
jobs are increasingly coming to resemble fast-food
or Walmart jobs, especially for those workers
employed through temporary staffing agencies.”
Copyright ©
1998-2016 World Socialist Web Site - All
rights reserved |