Now, consider the fact that according to
reports, "only 19.7 percent of
eligible New Yorkers cast a ballot, the
second-lowest voter turnout among
primary states after Louisiana,
according to elections expert Michael
McDonald".
This is not to mention the fact that
even those who were registered Democrats
and could not vote: "The Kings County
Board of Elections purged 126,000
registered Democrats from the voting
rolls in Brooklyn, prompting an outcry
from Mayor Bill de Blasio and an audit
from Comptroller Scott Stringer."
Whatever the cause of this "purge"
(fraud or mishap), this is not the main
calamity of the electoral process in the
US.
The issue is the fact that less than 20
percent of eligible voters in a
statewide election get to choose who the
next presidential candidates in the US
national elections would be.
This low number is not any indication of
an apathetic low voter turnout, but, in
fact, is the evidence of massive voter
suppression that, in the racist parlance
of the white supremacists, is kept
exclusive for what they call "Third
World Banana Republics".
Now, the question is very simple: What
is the difference between the way the
Democratic Party functions in New York
and many other states and the Communist
Party of North Korea, the bete noire of
the liberation theologians singing
Hallelujah for "American democracy"?
Since when can a political party (with
an obvious political agenda to promote
for its own endurance) violate the
inalienable right of citizenship in a
republic?
Some
more equal than others
The principle reason for this voter
suppression is what they call in the US
"closed primaries". What is a closed
primary?
New York is among many other states that
conduct what is called "closed
primaries"; namely, they only allow
voters who are registered members of a
particular political party to vote in
that party's primary.
It
is not, therefore, accidental that much
to the
chagrin of Sanders and his massive
supporters among independents, "Clinton
has won every state so far that's held a
closed primary".
If, as a citizen, you followed the
debates closely and came to the
conclusion that Sanders is the candidate
of your choice and not Clinton, you
would not be allowed to vote for him
unless months ago (long before you were
familiar with Sanders or his ideas), you
had applied to the Democratic Party and
become a member.
It
must be a rudimentary fact of any claim
to democracy that if you are a citizen
of a republic, you must be able to vote
in any phase of any presidential (or any
other) election simply by virtue of
being a citizen.
But in this crucial phase of the US
presidential primaries, these citizens
are not allowed to vote unless and until
they are card-carrying members of the
political party conducting that
primary.
"All animals are equal," indeed, as we
learned from George Orwell's Animal
Farm, "but some animals are more equal
than others".
As
a result of this blatantly undemocratic
practice, if you are an
independent-minded person, follow the
news and watch the debates before you
decide which candidate you prefer and
want to vote for in the Democratic
primaries in New York, you might as well
be a woman trying to drive in Saudi
Arabia: You could not.
False
claim to democracy
The Democratic Party, therefore, rules
over this false claim to democracy the
same way the Guardian Council of
octogenarian Super Mullahs rules over
the Islamic Republic.
In
other words, the free and fair formation
of political parties that is supposed to
be the finest fruit of a democracy has
paradoxically degenerated into the most
powerful impediment to democracy.
The question is: What is the result of
these undemocratic "closed primaries"?
These "closed primaries" are the
bottlenecks of a closed political
culture, preventing the possibility of
any liberating breakthrough into a
foreclosed political system.
At
the heart of this imperial republic that
effectively rules the world with its
military might (not with any moral
courage or political legitimacy), we
have an electoral process that
systematically bars any critical
judgment of its own citizens to disrupt
its mindless militarism. American
citizens are as much trapped inside this
corrupt system as people around the
globe are at the mercy of its fighter
jets and drone attacks.
These two parties, Republican and
Democratic, are today functioning like
two identical but competing Orwellian
Ministries of Truth - systematically,
consistently, unabashedly disallowing
any critical thinking or nonviolent
democratic action to enter and disrupt
the always-already rigged election.
Hamid Dabashi is Hagop Kevorkian
Professor of Iranian Studies and
Comparative Literature at Columbia
University.