April 18, 2016 "Information
Clearing House"
- A study,
to appear in the Fall 2014 issue of the
academic journal Perspectives on
Politics, finds that the U.S. is no
democracy, but instead an oligarchy,
meaning profoundly corrupt, so that the
answer to the study’s opening question,
"Who governs? Who really rules?" in this
country, is:
"Despite the seemingly strong empirical
support in previous studies for theories
of majoritarian democracy, our analyses
suggest that majorities of the
American public actually have little
influence over the policies our
government adopts. Americans do enjoy
many features central to democratic
governance, such as regular elections,
freedom of speech and association, and a
widespread (if still contested)
franchise. But, ..." and then they go on
to say, it's not true, and that,
"America's claims to being a democratic
society are seriously threatened" by the
findings in this, the first-ever
comprehensive scientific study of the
subject, which shows that there is
instead "the nearly total failure of
'median voter' and other Majoritarian
Electoral Democracy theories [of
America]. When the preferences of
economic elites and the stands
of organized interest groups are
controlled for, the preferences of the
average American appear to have only a
minuscule, near-zero, statistically
non-significant impact upon public
policy."
To
put it short: The United States is no
democracy, but actually an oligarchy.
The authors of this historically
important study are Martin Gilens and
Benjamin I. Page, and their article is
titled "Testing
Theories of American Politics." The
authors clarify that the data available
are probably under-representing the
actual extent of control of the U.S. by
the super-rich:
Economic Elite Domination theories
do rather well in our analysis, even
though our findings probably
understate the political influence
of elites. Our measure of the
preferences of wealthy or elite
Americans – though useful, and the
best we could generate for a large
set of policy cases – is probably
less consistent with the relevant
preferences than are our measures of
the views of ordinary citizens or
the alignments of engaged interest
groups. Yet we found
substantial estimated effects even
when using this imperfect measure.
The real-world impact of elites upon
public policy may be still greater.
Nonetheless, this is the first-ever
scientific study of the question of
whether the U.S. is a democracy. "Until
recently it has not been possible to
test these contrasting theoretical
predictions [that U.S. policymaking
operates as a democracy, versus as an
oligarchy, versus as some mixture of the
two] against each other within a single
statistical model. This paper reports on
an effort to do so, using a unique data
set that includes measures of the key
variables for 1,779 policy issues."
That’s an enormous number of
policy-issues studied.
What the authors are able to find,
despite the deficiencies of the data, is
important: the first-ever scientific
analysis of whether the U.S. is a
democracy, or is instead an oligarchy,
or some combination of the two. The
clear finding is that the U.S. is an
oligarchy, no democratic country, at
all. American democracy is a sham, no
matter how much it's pumped by the
oligarchs who run the country (and who
control the nation's "news" media). The
U.S., in other words, is basically
similar to Russia or most other dubious
"electoral" "democratic" countries. We
weren't formerly, but we clearly are
now. Today, after this exhaustive
analysis of the data, “the preferences
of the average American appear to have
only a minuscule, near-zero,
statistically non-significant impact
upon public policy.” That's it, in a
nutshell.