The
[Redacted] Truth about the CIA
America's most notorious spy agency even deceives
its own employees.
By John Kiriakou
March 01, 2016 "Information
Clearing House"
- "Other
Words"
- It’s no secret that the CIA isn’t always up front
with the public about its operations. You may even
be kept in the dark if you’re an elected official.
But did you know the agency even lies to its own
employees?
That’s the
subject of a recent Washington Post report
on a
heretofore unknown practice at the CIA called “eyewashing.”
Before
moving to the substance of the article, however, I
owe my readers an explanation: The Central
Intelligence Agency must approve of everything I
write about
intelligence, the CIA, foreign policy, diplomacy,
the military, and national security — for the
rest of my life.
They didn’t
like this column, even though the source material is
freely available to anybody who reads the Post.
The CIA consented to let me run it, but only if I
redacted a few important sections.
I’ve
decided to show you the CIA’s cuts, rather than
engage in a protracted negotiation.
Now, back
to eyewashing. Eyewashing, simply put, is a way that
the CIA deceives its own employees.
According
to the Post, CIA veterans described
eyewashing as an “important security measure” and a
“means of protecting vital secrets by inserting fake
communications into routine cable traffic.” But
these lies eventually are passed to Congress, too.
And when
documents are finally declassified, the lies make
their way to historians and to the American people.
Here’s how eyewashing works.
Let’s say a
CIA officer is working on a sensitive operation in
the field. He’s reporting his progress to
headquarters, and the operation becomes even more
sensitive.
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX.
Investigators from the Senate Intelligence Committee
found at least two instances where the CIA turned
over eyewashed cables for the committee’s report on
torture. Both related to Abu Zubaydah, an alleged
al-Qaeda operative the CIA believed — incorrectly —
XXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX.
This
practice is ripe for abuse.
What
happens when an officer decides to issue a deceptive
“eyewash” cable to his coworkers because the source
— or the officer — is doing something illegal or
unethical? With the eyewash cable in place,
congressional oversight committees would have no
idea.
Interestingly, the Post article said that
most former senior CIA officers interviewed,
including attorneys, had never heard of the
practice.
That means
it wasn’t passed through the chain of command. No
legal opinions were issued. The inspector general
didn’t know it was happening. While those who did
know about the practice claimed it didn’t get out of
hand, you’ll just have to take their word for it.
Plainly, there’s no adult supervision in the CIA.
Imagine
what can happen if we accept that our public
servants can simply lie.
Why not
eyewash a torture program? Why not eyewash a secret
prison system? Where does it end?
And more
importantly, how can it end at all if nobody except
the perpetrators knows it’s happening in the first
place?
The CIA may
tell you that eyewash cables are important to
protecting sources and operations. What I would tell
you is that it’s forbidden by federal law.
Indeed,
it’s a criminal offense to “conceal,
cover up, falsify, or make a false entry“ into
an official record. It’s called “making a false
statement,” and it’s punishable by five years
imprisonment. There’s no legal exemption for the
CIA.
It’s in the
CIA’s nature to lie, even to its congressional
overseers. But that doesn’t mean the American people
should stand for it.
OtherWords columnist John Kiriakou is an
associate fellow at the Institute for Policy
Studies. A former CIA counterterrorism officer,
he led the operation to capture Abu Zubaydah.
|