Beached
America
By Robert C.
Koehler
February
18, 2016 "Information
Clearing House"
- For at least the last four decades now I feel like
I’ve been living in Beached America: a nation that
has lost its values, even as it writhes in violent
agitation, inflicting its military on the vulnerable
regions of the planet.
It does so
in the name of those lost values . . . democracy,
freedom, equality. These are just dead words at this
point, public relations blather, silently followed
by a sigh: yada, yada, yada. Then we send in the
drones.
This is the
behavior of a nation that is spiritually beached.
Ideas that could open up the future have long been
gagged, mocked and marginalized, locked in a closet
somewhere. No way can they be allowed to have
political influence. Thanks, mainstream media.
Here, for
instance, is the
Washington Post, holding forth on the death of
Antonin Scalia and the looming congressional impasse
over the appointment of his successor. Rather than
dig for what’s at stake, Post writer James Hohmann
merely revels in the political gamesmanship of it
all. Mitch McConnell’s decision to use the
Republican Senate majority to block the president’s
replacement choice is, he writes, “a bold and
understandable gambit designed to prevent a leftward
lurch in jurisprudence.”
But:
“Assuming the president picks a Hispanic, African
American or Asian American — bonus points if she’s a
woman — this could be exactly what Democrats need to
re-activate the Obama coalition that fueled his
victories in 2008 and 2012.”
I quote
these words simply because they’re typical of a
media that has utterly divested its reportage of
depth and value. They merrily describe the contours
of the game of Big Politics to American news
consumers. Bonus points if she’s a woman!
Whatever
once mattered — civil rights, women’s rights, or the
denial thereof — has morphed into some sort of
meaningless political post-modernism, lots of yada
yada but we all know that winning is the only thing
that matters, and even that doesn’t really matter
because it changes nothing. The deep reality in
which we live cannot be touched.
This is
Beached America.
It is in
this context that I bring up
Michael
Moore’s new documentary, Where To Invade
Next, not because it’s without flaws but
because, my God, it rips back the surface of
American politics and frees a fair number of
imprisoned concepts — like, oh, forgiveness,
childhood creativity, the honest embrace of one’s
own history — and sets them loose in the present
moment.
These
concepts, or rather, this depth of possibility for a
better, more compassionate world that they
represent, which had political momentum up through
the ’60s and early ’70s, when various movements —
civil rights, of course, followed by the anti-war
movement, feminism, gay rights, environmentalism —
shattered Jim Crow and crashed the American
political scene, have been stalled and muted, banned
from presidential politics, reduced to an obscenity
called “political correctness,” since Reagan, since
Nixon.
This is
Beached America.
Remarkably,
this depth of possibility has made its presence felt
in the 2016 presidential race. The
media-corporate-military consensus that has claimed
control over the national destiny for more than four
decades is trembling. Possibility and human hope are
coming back to life in the campaign for Bernie
Sanders, who finally has begun putting his proposed
social programs into the context of recklessly
unchecked military spending: “When we went to war in
Iraq, the trillions we spent there, not a problem,”
he said this week in Michigan, comparing this to the
dearth of funding available to solve Flint’s water
crisis.
Also coming
back to life in this campaign are the opposite of
such ideas: the good old days of Jim Crow racism,
blustering forth in the voice of Donald Trump, which
has freed itself from political correctness.
Into these
roiling waters paddles Michael Moore. The
faux-premise of Where To Invade Next is that
America’s military leaders, beside themselves over
the utter failure of their wars since the Big One
that ended in 1945, have asked for Moore’s advice
about what to do next. This sends him on a literal
tour of eight European countries, plus Tunisia, in
search of something the United States can grab
abroad other than oil.
What
resonates about the ideas he “steals” from these
countries is that they have serious depth and social
implication. They only make sense in a social
context devoted to the liberation of human potential
— a conviction that that’s the point of our social
structure.
Some of the
ideas are fairly simple: more paid vacation time for
workers (Italy), better lunches for schoolchildren
(France). But they begin escalating in complexity —
and controversy — as Moore forges across Europe.
In Norway,
for instance, he looks at the prison system, which
is truly focused on healing rather than punishment.
In Norway’s maximum security prisons, convicted
murderers have the keys to their own rooms, which
look more like college dorms than medieval dungeons.
At one point, Moore even interviews the father of a
child murdered by Anders Breivik, the man who went
on a racist, anti-immigrant rampage in that country
in 2011, killing 77 people, most of them kids at a
summer camp. Breivik was given a mere 21 years in
prison. The dad talked about forgiveness.
Forgiveness! Is there a riskier concept to bring to
the American public? The day after Breivik’s
rampage, Mayor Fabian Stang of Oslo said, “I don’t
think security can solve problems. We need to teach
greater respect.” Moore reanimates this idea in his
movie, puts it forth as a value to embrace. Most of
the reviews I’ve read can’t mask their cynicism
about it. But forgiveness isn’t the simple act the
cynics see it as. Forgiving a terrible wrong means
transcending rather than perpetuating it. This takes
commitment and courage beyond anything our political
system asks of us, but, as Moore implies, this is
what the future asks of us.
In Germany,
Moore visits an elementary-school classroom in which
the students have been asked to bring an item
precious to them — something they’d take with them
if they were being forced to leave their homes
forever. Each child places his or her keepsake in a
suitcase, which symbolizes the suitcase of a
Holocaust victim. The teacher closes the suitcase.
The idea
Moore is stealing here is as “simple” as
forgiveness. Acknowledge your history. Acknowledge
your sins. America doesn’t acknowledge the genocide
of Native Americans and shrugs off its legacy of
slavery. At what cost?
What if
such questions found their way into our national
politics? Could real values — and their implications
— enter the debate? Could a spiritually beached
nation see a course for itself beyond endless war?
Robert Koehler is
an award-winning, Chicago-based journalist and
nationally syndicated writer. His book,
Courage Grows Strong at the Wound
(Xenos Press), is still
available. Contact him at
koehlercw@gmail.com or visit his website at
commonwonders.com.
© 2016
Common Wonders |