The Indispensable Nation, Exploded
By Karen KwiatkowskiOctober 02, 2015 "Information
Clearing House" - Americans like to
think that we revolted against injustice, embraced liberty, and
became a model for a new republic in 1776. The ideas of that
experimental, tiny precursor to the modern American empire have been
lost in translation over the centuries. Human tendencies to love
liberty and decentralization, to crave personal independence and the
right to build and create their own legacies, to be kings of their
own castles, remain, but they are in the mist in 2015 America.
For well over a dozen decades, the mythology that
we live in the best, most powerful, most influential, and most
envied nation that has ever existed has been force fed to a billion
past and present Americans. These beliefs are part and parcel of a
century of
neoconservativism. These beliefs unite what remains of the Tea
Party movement, and the Reform and the Bull Moose Parties before
that. They underpin the popular rhetoric of democratic socialist
Bernie Sanders. The Clinton and Bush dynasties embrace and evoke
these beliefs, and have substantial fundamental legitimacy among the
population as a result – regardless of how we distrust these
particular candidates. The rhetoric of populist
Democratic-Republican Donald Trump harmonizes perfectly with deeply
held beliefs about American exceptionalism and militarism.
The 2016 choice is clear, singular, and irrelevant
– anyone leading in the polls today would make an acceptable
President, and both parties are united in state worship, couched in
the idea of Washington, DC as the center of the universe, the
indispensable capital of the world. When the population is asked,
“What kind of ice cream do you like?” the real question, impossible
to ask but necessary for our very survival, is “Do we want any
more?” Many Americans still do want more, and the crony capitalist
class, government-connected bankster class, and the staggering array
of government dependencies throughout the country certainly do want
more. They need more, and face an early and painful extinction if
they don’t get more.
Our Depression era grandparents would squeeze a
lemon dry and use the rind. And so will the modern D.C.
dependencies, that exist on redistributive allocations of stolen GDP
and subsidized borrowing against future stolen GDP. These organisms
–sustained by tax-eating and unwise borrowing – will squeeze that
fount dry and consume the remainder, before they give up the ghost.
When the entities finally do say die, they will
mean it. In the battle for bureaucratic survival, the odds will
favor the armed and popular, i.e. the armed. This is always the end
of tyrannies, and of empires. The present day public popularity of
military and police may reveal a subconscious sense that here is
where survival power is, that in the military state many will find
protection, as dog eats dog.
Thus, we see both government welfare and
conservative “values” advocates boldly embrace the use of state
force, and instinctively refuse to threaten the existence or even
the budgets of the massive and growing armed bureaucracies. The
bureaucratic wolves, sensing a cold winter approaching, have
prepared, by expanding the wars overseas while expanding domestic
presence, through militarized policing, massive and pervasive
government surveillance and documenting of citizen movements,
investments, and transactions, and a wholly incompetent but
incredibly useful “homeland” security infrastructure.
As our subconscious sense of a “need” for state
survival impresses on us the value of the militarist and force heavy
state, the current ongoing wars in a dozen countries – mysterious in
detail, convoluted in motive, reported mechanically if at all,
celebrated by all major political parties or voices — are losing
moral ground and physical territory in all cases. The Pentagon
moans at loss of its “war” budget justification and cries at what
sequestration has done to its “regular, non-war” and continually
expanding operating budget. The very fact that this third century
of America has not only blown in with the world’s largest standing
military, but that this institution budgets for war separately
(and unarguably) from its own existential maintenance as the largest
military on earth.
The indispensable nation today is not centered in
Washington, DC or even NYC. Today, for today, it is centered in
Moscow. How fascinating that a former Soviet man, a modern-day
dictator by most reports, a man who faces down domestic antiwar
sentiment and critiques with prison sentences, has shown the
decisiveness and will in stomping the named American enemy of the
moment. Putin’s successful air attacks on the dread pirate ISIS in
Syria have provided a big ideological challenge to American
fantasies and frightened the deciders in Washington to their very
core.
In calling the neoconservative, Republicrat bluff
that ISIS is an enemy of the US (rather than the US-facilitated
means for toppling the last independent secular leader in the Middle
East, setting the stage for endless wars, reliable higher oil
prices, and a ballooning US national security budget into the next
several decades), the new indispensable nation (or at least Putin
and his military) has inadvertently exploded the driving and
unifying myth of American indispensability. He has, in one swift
move, both clarified the issues and exposed the D.C. mob.
In another era, the shrieks from Washington about
the cheeky Putin and the potentially cheeky Chinese, might have
worked to turn the herd. But as with the era that preceded the
British loss of the American colonies, the current king in the
United States, a modern George III, is widely believed to be crazy,
obsessed, wasteful, debt ridden and unlikeable. His popular
opposition – while statists and militarists all, owe their
popularity to how well they articulate (without really believing it
themselves) the growing and real perspective that the king is a
naked, lying, incompetent puppet and should be overthrown.
But popular politics in an empire is no match for
bureaucratic survival of an all consuming and powerful central
state. Putin’s move has delivered the happy and undeniable
rationale for the immediate end of the U.S. warfare state, and has
in one act, collapsed the core tenet of neoconservatism, the RNC and
the DNC. But the word on this isn’t yet out to the hinterlands, and
we must expect that it will be directly suppressed and creatively
propagandized by government media outlets as a rationale for even
more Washington, D.C. spending, assertiveness, and militarism. The
leading presidential candidates will predictably use their platforms
to articulate the needs of the state, over all else.
Washington D.C.
is preparing to be burned. The state’s terror may be due to how
they learned to stop worrying and love the bomb, or growing fear of
domestic revolts against the symbols of overweening government. I
suspect that the state’s terror is the result of internecine
bureaucratic warfare gone hot in a collapsing Empire’s desperate
capital. Terror within the (deep) state has an immediate symptom,
and it is state terror. With Russia directly and successfully
exploding the myth of America the indispensable nation, we may
cautiously celebrate the long contest for real liberty. But we
should expect the very worst in immediate outcomes, and not
underestimate the fury of our faltering and desperate central
government in coming months.
Karen U. Kwiatkowski, is an American activist
and commentator. She is a retired U.S. Air Force Lieutenant Colonel
whose assignments included duties as a Pentagon desk officer and a
variety of roles for the National Security Agency.