Greatest Threat to Free Speech Comes Not From Terrorism, But
From Those Claiming to Fight it
By Glenn Greenwald
May 13, 2015 "Information
Clearing House" - "The
Intercept" - We learned recently
from Paris that the western world is deeply and passionately committed to
free expression and ready to march and fight against attempts to suppress
it. That’s a really good thing, since there are all sorts of severe suppression
efforts underway in the west – perpetrated not by The Terrorists but by the
western politicians claiming to fight them.
One of the most alarming examples comes, not at all
surprisingly, from the UK Government, which is
currently agitating for new counter-terrorism powers “including plans for
extremism disruption orders designed to restrict those trying to radicalize
young people.” Here are the powers which the British Freedom Fighters and
Democracy Protectors are seeking:
They would include a ban on broadcasting and a
requirement to submit to the police in advance any proposed publication on
the web and social media or in print. The bill will also contain
plans for banning orders for extremist organisations which
seek to undermine democracy or use hate speech in public places, but it will
fall short of banning on the grounds of provoking hatred.
It will also contain new powers to close premises
including mosques where extremists seek to influence others. The
powers of the Charity Commission to root out charities that misappropriate
funds towards extremism and terrorism will also be strengthened.
In essence, advocating any ideas or working for any political
outcomes regarded by British politicians as “extremist” will not only be a
crime, but can be physically banned in advance. Basking in his election victory,
Prime Minister David Cameron
unleashed this Orwellian decree to explain why new Thought Police powers are
needed: “For too long, we have been a passively tolerant society, saying to our
citizens ‘as long as you obey the law, we will leave you alone.'” It’s not
enough for British subjects merely to “obey the law”; they must refrain from
believing in or expressing ideas which Her Majesty’s Government dislikes.
If all that sounds menacing, tyrannical and even fascist to
you — and really, how could it not? “extremism disruption orders” — you
should really watch this
video of Tory Home Secretary Theresa May try to justify the bill in an
interview on BBC this morning. When pressed on what “extremism” means –
specifically, when something crosses the line from legitimate disagreement into
criminal “extremism” – she evades the question completely, instead repeatedly
invoking creepy slogans about the need to stop those who seek to “undermine Our
British Values” and, instead, ensure “we are together as one society, One
Nation” (I personally believe this was all more lyrical in its original German).
Click here to watch the
video and see the face of western authoritarianism, advocating powers in the
name of Freedom that are its very antithesis.
Threats to free speech can come from lots of places. But right
now, the greatest threat by far in the west to ideals of free expression is
coming not from radical Muslims, but from the very western governments claiming
to fight them. The increasingly unhinged, Cheney-sounding governments of the UK,
Australia, France, New Zealand and Canada — joining the U.S. — have
a seemingly insatiable desire to curb freedoms in the name of protecting
them:
prosecuting people for
Facebook postings critical of Western militarism or
selling
“radical” cable channels,
imprisoning people for “radical” tweets,
banning websites containing ideas they dislike,
seeking (and
obtaining) new
powers of surveillance and detention for those people (usually though not
exclusively Muslim citizens) who hold and espouse views deemed by these
governments to be “radical.”
Anticipating Prime Minister Cameron’s new “anti-extremist”
bill (to be unveiled in the “Queen’s Speech”), University of Bath Professor Bill
Durodié
said that “the window for free speech has now been firmly shut just a few
months after so many political leaders walked in supposed solidarity for
murdered cartoonists in France.” Actually, there has long been a broad,
sustained assault in the west on core political liberties – specifically due
process, free speech and free assembly – perpetrated not by “radical Muslims”
but by those who endlessly claim to fight them. Sadly, and tellingly, none of
that has triggered parades or marches or widespread condemnation by
western journalists and pundits. But for those who truly believe in principles
of free expression – as opposed to pretending to when it allows one to bash the
Other Tribe – these are the assaults that need marches and protests.
© First Look Media. All Rights Reserved