Who are the Real Barbarians - The West or
Muslims?
By Mahboob A. Khawaja
March 24, 2015
"ICH"
-
The US and the Europeans see war as an
instrument of political hegemony and control
over the precious natural resources of the
Arab-Muslim world. The super-ego American
and the allied Europeans are missing sense
of guilt for the vice and ruins of decade
long occupation and destruction of Iraq and
Afghanistan. To heighten the demands of
human conscience, Arab masses view them
barbarians of a new age more savage than
their predecessors crusader of the 12the
century.
Incapacity joined by insane egoism makes
complacent oil producing Arab rulers to
follow the Western dictates despite internal
challenges and intrigues of their
governance. Temptation and compulsion of
evil and failure of moral and intellectual
leadership have jeopardized the present and
future of whole of the Arab-Muslim world.
Viewing the mental microscope, aggressive
sectarian daily bloodbaths and
militarization have articulated a sense of
unreality.
Morally indifferent and
intellectually exhausted and incapacitated
as they look, Arab and Muslim leaders are
waiting and waiting to see what happens
next, missing initiative and new imagination
to the world of reason and prevalent reality
– planned violence and resulting cruelty are
becoming the societal hallmark across the
Arab-Muslim world. They wait for miracle to
happen out of nothing. Exclusive materialism
and militarization have devastated the Arab
traditional culture and psyche. Perhaps
petro-dollar transitory prosperity has
removed the sense of fear and shame to
embolden them to commit any crimes against
the human nature and the people. The
struggle is between the Western supported
authoritarianism and the reasoning for
political change by the Arab masses. All and
everybody is fighting. Throughout the
century, Arabs have lost the battles. The
leaders appear entrenched in a new
barbarianism unknown in human annals. If one
is asked, what are they fighting for? There
is no logical connection to the on-going
American-led war against ISIL or the
Iranian-operated Shiite group Al-Badr and
others committing crimes against the
Sunnis-Shiite and minorities. There is no
moral in a proxy war. All belligerent acts
enjoin their own intents and motives.
The Arab and Muslim world is
turning into complete political cruelty and
quagmire. Man killing fellow man, all
killing all, and reason not to be
questioned. The leaders and people appear to
be on the same page of bloodbath, insecurity
and breathing oxygen in a conflicting time
zone falling apart into the unknown. They
believe in nothing as if the Earth was
dormant, as if there is no God and life
ceases to have a noble purpose of peace,
harmony and co-existence. Western war
strategists are a crucial factor in bringing
them to this perverted status-quo of moral
and human equilibrium. In an advanced 21st
century of knowledge, wisdom and
information, man remains ignorant and
arrogant of his wrong thinking. Arab-Muslim
authoritarianism enforced by the self-image
to commit planned violence and aggression
against the revolutionary masses is
radiating across Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Egypt,
Libya and Bahrain. After five years, the
global community is just a symbolic
spectator watching the heinous crimes of the
few against many.
There is no World Order in
place to protect the victims of the on-going
bloody atrocities. There is no International
Law to forbid the disorder. Most Arab-Muslim
leaders lack capacity to imagine a viable
political future and understanding of the
purpose of human life and its priorities
within the scope of living Earth and living
Universe in which there is stern
accountability of man in relation to time
and place. How should this man-made cruelty
and prevalent anarchy be stopped and mankind
is saved from the scourge of bloody
sectarian and highly politicized war gone so
wrong and becoming unthinkable in
consequences?
Had they believed in God,
humanity and purpose of life with defined
accountability, the Earth could have been a
better place for all to co-exist peacefully.
The outrageous sectarian divides and
killings of Sunnis, Shiite, Christians and
other minorities in the Arab societies are
reaching to an appalling catastrophic
magnitude. Does the informed global
community want to see the Arab world to
determine its own sadistic ending? Killing
unjustifiably one innocent human being is
like killing of the whole of the humanity.
The global warlords represent cruel mindset
incapable to see the human side of the
living conscience. William T. Hathaway (“America
is under Attack!”
Dissident Voice), author of A World of Hurt
and an adjunct Professor of American
Studies, University of Oldenburg, Germany,
attempts to clarify how the US and Britain
have culminated havoc world of atrocities in
the Arab Middle East:
“The
USA and Britain committed similar atrocities
in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Libya, Indonesia,
and Afghanistan. We overthrew their
governments, installed dictators, undermined
their economies — all to strengthen our
business interests. In every nation where we
now have terrorism, we had first assaulted
them. America is under attack only because
it is on the attack. It’s no wonder they
hate us. Imagine how we would feel if a
foreign country were doing this to us. We’d
be fighting back any way we could……
If people knew this — knew
how easy it would be to stop terrorism —
they wouldn’t want to fight this war. That’s
why the media ignore al-Qaeda’s demands.
Western leaders don’t want people to see
that the war’s real purpose isn’t to stop
terrorism but to control the resources of
this region. They actually want the
terrorism because that gives them the excuse
they need — the threat of an evil enemy.”
Who are the Real
Barbarians - Western or Muslims?
“It was under
the influence of Arabian and Moorish
revival of culture and not in the
fifteenth century, that the real
Renaissance took place. Spain not
Italy, was the cradle of the rebirth
of Europe...It is highly probable
that but for the Arabs modern
European civilization would never
have arisen at all; it is absolutely
certain that but for them, it would
not have assumed that character
which has enabled it to transcend
all previous phases of evolution.
For although there is not a single
aspect of European growth in which
the decisive influence of Islamic
culture is not traceable, nowhere is
it so clear and momentous as in the
genesis of that power which
constitutes the paramount
distinctive force of the modern
world and the supreme source of its
victory.” Robert Briffault,
Professor Cambridge University (The
Making of Humanity,
London, 1919).
Arabs were once the
pioneer of knowledge-based sustainable
civilization lasting for 800 years – the
longest period in human history. Today, the
former colonial thinkers and occupiers
describe the Arabs and Muslims as
“extremists”, ‘terrorists” and barbarians.”
Throughout the 20th century and
well into the 21st century, the
oil richness failed to deal with emerging
social, moral, intellectual and political
problems. Instead with militarization of the
region, increasing bloodbaths depicts a
havoc political spectrum- floating without
roots and reason. Islam enriched the Arabs
to become global leaders of a progressive
civilization, but the oil enhanced
prosperity transformed them into ‘camel
jockeys’ and object of hallow laughers after
dinner jokes in the Western culture. When
the Arabs had a missionary zeal to “forbid
evil and invite mankind towards goodness”,
they excelled in human change, moral
leadership, material progress and
civilization. Money cannot buy wisdom, honor
and human integrity. The late Saudi King
Abdullah and Sheikh Sabha al-Sabah of Kuwait
were both complacent in providing logistic
support to George Bush’s 2003 invasion of
Iraq and the massacre of approximately three
millions Iraqis during the prolonged
occupation. The bogus “war on terrorism”
could not have happened if the Arab leaders
- the frontline bogyman of the US Empire had
useful mind, intellectual capacity and
integrity to challenge the most irrational
and cruel act in human history. The Arabs
created a knowledge-enshrined pioneering
culture of tolerance, encompassing various
ethnicities, faiths and languages -- thus
inspiring the development of everything from
mathematics to astronomy, medical sciences,
poetry, and imagination of futuristic human
civilization, education, law and justice,
splendid architect defy gravity onward to
library science and lot more.
The Arab-Muslim world
failed to produce any leader of vision and
intellectual integrity for the changing and
complex global affairs of the 21st
century. When Arabs were the leaders in
Faith (‘Emaan’) and human values, they
articulated a unique civilization tolerant
of diversity and varied cultural ethnicities
and built upon the unity of Islamic faith to
nurture peaceful co-existence and human
development. If you list the discoveries and
contributions of Muslim scholars, they are
countless. Do you know any other scientists
or scholars whose contributions were used in
text books for six centuries in European
medical schools? Consider Mohammad Hussein
Bu Ali Sina's Cannon of Medicine.
The Europeans changed his name to Avicenna
so that nobody would recognize that he was a
Muslim scholar. It is said that Ibna Sina
alone discovered and authenticated 36
pharmaceutical formulas being used to this
day.
Marai Rosa Menocal (A Golden Reign of
Tolerance: The Ornament of the World: How
Muslims, Jews and Christians Created a
Culture of Tolerance in Medieval Spain,
2003),
explains: "The lessons of history, like the
lessons of religion, sometime neglect
examples of tolerance. A thousand years ago
on the Iberian Peninsula, an enlightened
vision of Islam had created the most
advanced culture in Europe....In Cordoba,
the library housed some 400,000 volumes at a
time when the largest library in Latin
Christendom probably held no more than 400."
Daily
barrel bombs across Syria, Jehadi car
bombings in Baghdad, Houti’s led
Iranian-backed Shiite insurgency in Yemen,
bloody street encounters in Cairo and
Tripoli – millions are being displaced and
wiped out in seconds as if they were not
human beings - all tell of a dehumanized
Arab culture of irreversible frightening
trend. The future is darkened by the forces
of evil. Violence and hatred are fast
sinking the large landscape of Arab-Muslim
societies into massive deaths and societal
destruction. Daily killing statistics
generate media-frenzy supporting Samuel
Huntington’s (“The
Clash of Civilizations”,
Foreign Affairs, 1993), claim of “Islam has
bloody borders.”
Would
America and Israel Determine the Future of
the New Middle East?
Are the Arab leaders
collaborating with the US and Israel policy
agenda to undermine the Arab nation states
and the future of Palestine? The ultimate
goal is aimed at complete militarization,
destabilization and continuous destruction
of the people, culture and economic
environment of the Arab peninsula.
Throughout the oil exporting Arab world,
some of the contemporary rulers have turned
out to be complacent in the US-Israeli
strategic plans for the future of the Middle
East. The recent outcomes of the Israeli
political elections and return of PM
Netanyahu gives ample concerns that
Palestinian will face formidable problems in
pursuing the freedom goal out of the
continued occupation. Perhaps, Palestinians
need new, educated and proactive coherent
leadership to deal with the 21st
century’s critical political challenges.
Somehow neglecting the history, Israelis and
Palestinians are not overcoming the missing
humanitarian, moral and intellectual
communication norms and linkages. When the
European massacred and displaced Jews, Arabs
welcomed them in their own hearts and
governance extending excellence in human
dignity and political prominence in
An-Andalusia (Spain) and elsewhere. There is
an urgent societal need on both sides to
rethink and to capitalize on moral, social
and intellectual communications between the
Palestinians and Israelis to avert violence
and reject political hatred. Whenever any
antagonists keep means of communication open
and accessible, human problems could be
tackled by reason and necessity of the human
nature. Israelis and Palestinians are living
and informed entities and they must come up
with action plans to co-exist at human level
of decency and sustainable future. Denying
freedom to Palestinians would be a denial to
the freedom of self-oppressed Israelis
politically and intellectually with
continuing occupation and wars. None of the
Arab leaders have ever come out to represent
logically the public conscience on the issue
of Palestine and the establishment of an
independent homeland for the people of
Palestine. An internationally acclaimed
Canadian author, Eric Margolis (“Middle
East Peace is Buried”,
Information Clearing House: 3/21/2015)
brings home the much perceived reality:
Who is going to force Israel
to follow this sensible, two-state solution
to the misery of the Palestinian people?
Obama could not even stop Netanyahu from
coming to Washington and humiliating him
before Congress. Is Obama going to force
Israel and its 650,000 armed settlers out of
the West Bank? …..As for the Palestinians,
they don’t seem to have much hope. Chances
for even a rickety, feeble Bantustan state
on the West Bank are gone. Netanyahu
declared no Palestinian state at the end of
the elections race. He will, of course,
continue flirting with the US and EU over
this worn-out question, making small
tactical concessions to allow his western
allies to continue going along with the
charade that “peace talks” are still alive.
They are not and have not been for a
decade. It just suits the western powers to
continue this deceitful game while Israel
relentlessly annexes the Occupied
Territories.
In view of the unstoppable
cycle of political killings and daily
bloodbaths in so many Arab states - Syria,
Iraq, Yemen, Egypt, Libya, Tunis, Bahrain
and spill-over to other oil producing Arab
nations - and continuing militancy of the
ISIL and its chain reactionary rivalries of
other extremist groups, vengeful deaths and
destruction unleashed by the Iranian backed
Shiite militias in Iraq, Syria and the
Houtis in Yemen and dismantling of the
socio-economic infrastructures - is the Arab
world coming to its own end? None of the
Arab leaders seem to care or to think of
creative political initiatives and measures
to stop the cycle of sectarian killings and
massive destabilization of the region. Any
objective-oriented analysis will point out
that Arab authoritarian leaders
interdependent on America and Britain expect
their masters to come and rescue them in
political crises. Obviously, America and
Britain enjoin their own political and
military agenda and follow it through.
How to Change Political
Insanity into Moral Reasoning?
One finds a fatal
deficiency in the mindset of the Arab-Muslim
leadership – a moral and intellectual
behavioral sinking with missing soul of
curiosity and internal mindedness. In
situations of crisis and unusual
emergencies, competent and responsible
leaders do not look towards convenient
escape from reality but get engaged and
extend intellectual security to manage
problems. What is the cure to raging
indifference and cruelty to the interests of
the people of the Arab-Muslim world,
America, Europe and for that matter to the
whole of the global community? Looking at
the Nature of Things, the universe
encompasses many challenging opposites -
time, space, sun, moon, gravitational
rotation of the earth, fire, water, air,
sand, floods, earthquakes, tsunami,
disasters, explosions, wars, destructions,
bombing and all that can be imagined to
destroy the mankind and endanger the
continued movement of the splendid,
inspiring and harmonious Universe. How it is
that Man - a creation of God cannot co-exist
with fellow Man? Is Man by nature a blood
thirsty creature? Why should few West
European leaders and President Obama have
free hand in launching bombing campaigns and
killing the innocents in Iraq, Afghanistan
and Syria? Would they dare to do the same
against Russia in the Ukraine crisis? What
rights do these insane barbarians enjoin to
engage in military intervention and massacre
the innocents in Afghanistan, Iraq, Yemen
and Syria day in and day out? American
shifting metaphor in policy will not end the
Syrian bloodbath. It shows how the ill-fated
bombing coalition against ISIL is futile and
meaningless. All Western leaders are playing
sadistic games of survival and exploitation.
Dictators never reason but dictate and so
the landscape of the Iraq-Syrian conflicts.
When would this planned and continuing
cruelty come to an end? Is there a sense of
superiority and indifference to the
interests of the global mankind? In its 2014
Global Thinkers statistics, Foreign Policy
(“A
World Disrupted: The global Thinkers of
2014”) pinpoints that
“something big requires a team rather than
an individual….” To enhance global peace
and to undo the bogus wars on terrorism,
there is an urgent need for teamwork by all
concerned not just the few self- addicted
warmongers who have consciously undermined
the vital interests of the mankind. The
teamwork if undertaken with unbiased mind
and without pre-conceived notions could
usher sustainable change and a new beginning
between those who claim to be at peace and
somewhat superior than the ordinary folks
and those who are fighting reactionary wars
of freedom against insanity and catastrophic
devastation of the human habitats.
To change the world into
peaceful co-existence and sustainable
harmony, it is incumbent upon the
intellectuals, academics, visionaries,
poets, philosophers and thinking hub of the
informed contemporary global community to
perceive and articulate new and creative
ideas, new political imagination for the 21st
century organizations to be functional for
the people, by the people and accountable to
the supremacy of the people’s will. Time and
encompassing opportunities warrant new
thinking and new leaders enriched with new
and innovative visions for change and
coherent future-making - The One Humanity.
But change and creativity and new visions
will not emerge out of the obsolete,
redundant and failed authoritarianism of the
few insane leaders. None have the
understanding of tangible peace or respect
for human life and co-existence in a
splendid Universe. To challenge the
deafening silence of the US and Europeans
(the powerful and hegemonic forces of the
world governing system), for global peace
and security, the global humanity must find
ways and means to look beyond the obvious
and troublesome horizons dominated by the
few warlords as if there were no rational
being and people of reason populating the
God-given living Universe. The informed and
mature global community looks towards those
Thinkers, educated and honest proactive
leaders enriched with coherent unity of
moral, spiritual, intellectual and physical
visions and abilities to be instrumental to
rescue it from the planned encroachment of
the few Western warlords. Wars never end but
obsess the succeeding generations with
unthinkable physical pains, psychological,
injuries and tormenting anguish to
dehumanized effects for ever. Pete Dolack (“The
Art of Becoming Human”,
Counterpunch: 3/13/2015) an activist,
writer, poet and photographer, blogs
Systemic Disorder;
attempts to share the first-hand life
experiences of the few US combatant soldiers
fighting the bogus war on terrorism in Iraq
and Afghanistan:
. …That
22 veterans commit suicide per day
is a grim reminder not only of the harsh
demands of military life but that the
Pentagon effectively throws away its
veterans after using them.
There are those whose
injuries are obvious, such as Tomas Young,
whose struggles were shown in full intensity
in the documentary Body of War. In
the
letter he wrote to George W. Bush and Dick
Cheney when his death was
impending, he put into words his agony:
“Your cowardice and
selfishness were established decades ago.
You were not willing to risk yourselves for
our nation but you sent hundreds of
thousands of young men and women to be
sacrificed in a senseless war with no more
thought than it takes to put out the
garbage. I have, like many other disabled
veterans, come to realize that our mental
and physical [disabilities and] wounds are
of no interest to you, perhaps of no
interest to any politician. We were used. We
were betrayed. And we have been abandoned.”
Kelly Dougherty, “talk
about my feelings of shame for participating
in a violent occupation.”
She writes:“When
I returned from Iraq ten years ago, some of
my most vivid memories were of pointing my
rifle at men and boys while my fellow
soldiers burned semi trucks of food and
fuel, and of watching the raw grief of a
family finding that their young son had been
run over and killed by a military convoy.
Are the Arab-Muslim
leaders waiting for the unthinkable
catastrophic end to their own life cycle and
time in history? To inhabit the world of new
political imagination beyond the obvious
horizon, these leaders could imagine the
same ending as happened to the Romans by
their own wishful constructs. Would the
estranged Arab leaders ever know and
understand the cruelty of
Wounds that can be seen and
those not seen!
Dr. Mahboob A. Khawaja specializes in global
security, peace and conflict resolution, and
comparative Western-Islamic cultures and
civilizations, and author of several
publications including the latest one:
Global Peace and Conflict Management: Man
and Humanity in Search of New Thinking.
Lambert Academic Publishing, Germany, May
2012