Why I’m Not Breaking Up
with America This Valentine’s Day
By John W. Whitehead
“I love America and I
hate it. I’m torn between the two. I
have two conflicting visions of America.
One is a kind of dream landscape and the
other is a kind of black comedy.”― Bono
February 14, 2015 "ICH"
- Almost every week I get an email from an
American expatriate living outside the
country who commiserates about the
deplorable state of our freedoms in the
United States, expounds on his great fortune
in living outside the continental U.S., and
urges me to leave the country before all
hell breaks loose and my wife and children
are tortured, raped, brutalized and killed.
Without fail, this
gentleman concludes every piece of
correspondence by questioning my sanity in
not shipping my grandchildren off to some
far-flung locale to live their lives free of
fear, police brutality, and surveillance.
I must confess that when
faced with unmistakable warning signs that
the country I grew up in is no more, I have
my own moments of doubt.
After all, why would
anyone put up with a government that
brazenly
steals, cheats, sneaks,
spies and lies, not to mention
alienates, antagonizes, criminalizes
and terrorizes its own citizens and then
justifies it in the name of safety, security
and the greater good?
Why would anyone put up
with
militarized police officers who
shoot first and ask questions later, act as
if their word is law, and operate as if they
are above the law?
Why would anyone put up
with government officials, it doesn’t matter
whether they’re elected or appointed, who
live an elitist lifestyle while setting
themselves apart from the populace, operate
outside the rule of law, and act as if
they’re beyond reproach and immune from
being held accountable?
Unfortunately, not only do
we put up with a laundry list of tyrannies
that make
King George III’s catalogue of abuses
look like child’s play, but most actually
persist in turning a blind eye to them,
acting as if what they don’t see or
acknowledge can’t hurt them.
The sad reality, as I make
clear in my book
A Government of Wolves: The Emerging
American Police State, is that
life in America is no bed of roses. Nor are
there any signs that things will get better
anytime soon, at least not for “we the
people,” those of us who belong to the
so-called “unwashed masses”—the working
class stiffs, the hoi polloi, the plebeians,
the rabble, the riffraff, the herd, the
peons and the proletariats.
For instance, we’re still
being spied on by our own government.
Incredibly, while the
British courts recognize that mass
government surveillance of cellphone and
online communications is not only illegal
but violates human rights, the U.S.
courts and politicians continue to pander to
the government’s whims, whether or not they
run afoul of the rule of law. Sen. Marco
Rubio (R-Fla.) actually wants to
make the NSA’s mass surveillance a permanent
practice.
Not only is the government
unapologetic about spying on its citizens,
but government agencies are using their
collective surveillance data to carry out
Orwellian pre-crime programs that attempt to
nab “criminals” before they ever commit a
crime. To do so, they have to study
our social media posts, our buying habits,
and where we travel to and from, and on and
on.
We’re still being treated
like serfs working for an overlord, with
little actual rights when it comes to our
property, our bodies, our children or our
welfare. It doesn’t really matter what the
justifications are for such taxes,
regulations, prohibitions and fines if they
result in us having little-to-no control
over how we live our lives. In Seattle, for
example, even
one’s trash is subject to government
regulation. Residents who fail to
separate out their food waste for composting
are fined for each violation.
We’re still bartering our
freedoms away for the phantom promise of
security, and we’re no safer and much less
freer than we were two decades ago. First,
it was the
Patriot Act, which continues to sanction all
manner of government intrusions into our
lives, from the government tracking
what cold medicine we use and how we spend
our money to what we read and with whom we
communicate. Then it was whole-body scanners
in the airports, which were
expensive, invasive and ineffective.
Most recently, we’ve been subjected to a
song-and-dance number about the
need for body cameras on police officers to
rein in abusive cops, with little
said about how these surveillance cameras
will be used to identify and track those in
their range, or how difficult the footage
will be to acquire if needed for our own
defense.
We’re still being fooled
into thinking that politics matter and that
there’s a difference between the Republicans
and Democrats, when in fact, the
two parties are exactly the same. As
one commentator
noted, both parties support endless
war, engage in out-of-control spending,
ignore the citizenry’s basic rights, have no
respect for the rule of law, are bought and
paid for by Big Business, care most about
their own power, and have a long record of
expanding government and shrinking liberty.
Our communities are still
being held hostage by militarized police.
Despite the fleeting attention paid to the
transformation of community police into
extensions of the military, the
transfer of military equipment from the
federal government to localities continues
unabated, with more than $28 million
worth of tactical equipment distributed in
the last quarter of 2014. The federal
government, in conjunction with local
police, has created a standing army on
American soil—something those who drafted
our Constitution believed would devastate
our freedoms.
We’re still exchanging one
set of wars for another, to the delight and
profit of the military industrial complex.
We’ve gone from waging war against Iraq and
Iran to
sounding the war drums against North Korea,
Syria and ISIS wherever it happens
to rear its head.
Every once in a while, we
get tossed a bone to satisfy that gnawing,
nagging hunger for something that looks and
tastes like freedom, democracy and free
enterprise. Political elections, town-hall
meetings, awards ceremonies, sports
spectacles,
high-dollar lotteries, reality TV
shows, morning news programs and
patriotic-themed blockbuster movies: these
are all the trappings of a so-called free
nation without the substance (what
Shakespeare referred to as a “tale told by
an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying
nothing”). Indeed, Big Business, in
conjunction with Big Government, have become
very adept at distracting the citizenry so
that “we the people” often have no clue as
to the real nature of the political game
being played.
Temporarily assuaged,
easily distracted and suffering from an
appalling case of public amnesia, we fall
right back into our complacency and
compliance, content to turn a blind eye to
blatant abuses, forgive past transgressions,
and forget all of the reasons why we should
be mad as hell about the state of our
nation.
So why do I stay? Why do
any of us continue to put up with the
gut-wrenching, soul-sucking,
misery-drenched, demoralizing existence that
is America today?
Perhaps I stay because I
was raised to believe that anything worth
having is worth fighting for, and I believe
with every fiber of my being that freedom
matters. In fact, I come from a long line of
Americans who understood that there is a
price to be paid for freedom, whether that
means standing up to the British military,
sitting down in a bus seat reserved for
“whites only,” or pushing back against
corporations who pollute our waters and
pillage our lands for profit.
Perhaps I soldier on
because I remember what it was like to grow
up at a time when the only surveillance I
had to worry about were the neighbors who
reported back to my mother whenever I did
something wrong, and I desperately want my
grandchildren to experience that kind of
carefree existence. I want them to know that
there’s more to life than metal detectors,
lockdowns, random searches and pre-crime
units trying to nab them for a crime if they
dare step out of line.
Perhaps I persevere
because I know that there are genuinely
concerned Americans out there, including
some good cops, honest politicians and
pragmatic idealists, who want to pitch in
and turn things around for the better. As
long as there is this small but vocal
minority who cares enough to stand up and
speak out, then all is not completely lost.
Perhaps I stick it out
because I know that surveillance,
overcriminalization, militarized police,
power-hungry politicians and greedy
corporations are not exclusive to America,
and there’s nowhere you can escape to where
tyranny cannot follow. No matter what you
think of Ronald Reagan and his politics, he
was right when he warned that, “If
we lose freedom here, there is no place to
escape to. This is the last stand on earth.”
Most of all, perhaps I
keep fighting on because I’m just not ready
to give up on America. At least, not yet.
In the words of that
revolutionary firebrand Patrick Henry:
Gentlemen may cry,
peace, peace — but there is no peace.
The war is actually begun! The next gale
that sweeps from the north will bring to
our ears the clash of resounding arms!
Our brethren are already in the field!
Why stand we here idle? What is it that
gentlemen wish? What would they have? Is
life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to
be purchased at the price of chains and
slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! — I
know not what course others may take;
but as for me, give me liberty or give
me death!
John W. Whitehead is an
attorney and author who has written, debated
and practiced widely in the area of
constitutional law and human rights.
Whitehead's concern for the persecuted and
oppressed led him, in 1982, to establish The
Rutherford Institute, a nonprofit civil
liberties and human rights organization
whose international headquarters are located
in Charlottesville, Virginia. Whitehead
serves as the Institute’s president and
spokesperson.