Greece Shows What Can
Happen When The Young Revolt Against Corrupt
Elites
By Paul Mason
January 25, 2015 "ICH"
- "The
Guardian" -
At
Syriza’s HQ, the cigarette smoke in the
cafe swirls into shapes. If those could
reflect the images in the minds of the men
hunched over their black coffees, they would
probably be the faces of Che Guevara, or
Aris Velouchiotis, the second world war
Greek resistance fighter. These are veteran
leftists who expected to end their days as
professors of such esoteric subjects as
development economics, human rights law and
who killed who in the civil war. Instead,
they are on the brink of power.
Black coffee and hard
pretzels are all the cafe provides, together
with the possibility of contracting lung
cancer. But on the eve of the vote, I found
its occupants confident, if bemused.
However, Syriza HQ is not
the place to learn about radicalisation. The
fact that a party with a “central committee”
even got close to power has nothing to do
with a sudden swing to Marxism in the Greek
psyche. It is, instead, testimony to three
things: the strategic crisis of the eurozone,
the determination of the Greek elite to
cling to systemic corruption, and a new way
of thinking among the young.
Of these, the eurozone’s
crisis is easiest to understand – because
its consequences can be read so easily in
the macroeconomic figures. The IMF predicted
Greece would grow as the result of its aid
package in 2010.
Instead, the economy has shrunk by 25%.
Wages are down by the same amount.
Youth unemployment stands at 60% – and
that is among those who are still in the
country.
So the economic collapse –
about which all Greeks, both right and
leftwing, are bitter – is not just seen as a
material collapse. It demonstrated complete
myopia among the European policy elite. In
all of drama and comedy there is no figure
more laughable as a rich man who does not
know what he is doing. For the past four
years the
troika – the European Commission, IMF and
European Central Bank – has provided
Greeks with just such a spectacle.
As for the Greek
oligarchs, their misrule long predates the
crisis. These are not only the famous
shipping magnates, whose industry pays no
tax, but the bosses of energy and
construction groups and football clubs. As
one eminent Greek economist told me last
week: “These guys have avoided paying tax
through the
Metaxas dictatorship, the Nazi
occupation, a civil war and a military
junta.” They had no intention of paying
taxes as the troika began demanding Greece
balance the books after 2010, which is why
the burden fell on those Greeks trapped in
the PAYE system – a workforce of 3.5 million
that fell during the crisis to just 2.5
million.
The oligarchs allowed the
Greek state to become a battleground of
conflicting interests. As Yiannis
Palaiologos, a Greek journalist, put it in
his recent book on the crisis, there is “a
pervasive irresponsibility, a sense that no
one is in charge, no one is willing or able
to act as a custodian of the common good”.
But their most corrosive
impact is on the layers of society beneath
them. “There goes X,” Greeks say to each
other as the rich walk to their tables in
trendy bars. “He is controlling Y in
parliament and having an affair with Z.”
It’s like a soap opera, but for real, and
too many Greeks are deferentially mesmerised
by it.
Over three general
elections Syriza’s achievement has been to
politicise the issue of the oligarchy. The
Greek word for them is “the entangled” – and
they were, above all, entangled in the
centrist political duopoly. Because Syriza
owes them nothing, its leader,
Alexis Tsipras, was able to give the
issue of corruption and tax evasion both
rhetorical barrels – and this resonated
massively among the young.
And here’s why. In a
functional market economy, the classic
couple in a posh restaurant are young and
close in age. In my travels through the
eurocrisis – from Dublin to Athens – I have
noticed that the classic couple in a
dysfunctional economy is a grey-haired man
with a twentysomething woman. It becomes a
story of old men with oligarchic power
flaunting their wealth and influence without
opprobrium.
The youth are usurped when
oligarchy, corruption and elite politics
stifle meritocracy. The sudden emergence of
small centrist parties led by charismatic
young professionals in
Greece is testimony that this generation
has had enough. But by the time they got
their act together, Tsipras was already
there.
From outside, Greece looks
like a giant negative: but what lies beneath
the rise of the radical left is the
emergence of positive new values – among a
layer of young people much wider than
Syriza’s natural support base. These are the
classic values of the networked generation:
self-reliance, creativity, the willingness
to treat life as a social experiment, a
global outlook.
When Golden Dawn emerged
as a frightening, violent neo-Nazi force,
with – at one point – 14% support, what
struck the networked youth was how many of
the political elite pandered to it. People
who had read its history could see a replay
of late Weimar flickering before their eyes:
delusional Nazis feted by big businessmen
craving for order.
I’ve reported the Greek
crisis since it began, and what changed in
2015 was this: Syriza had already won the
solid support of about 25% of voters on the
issues of
Europe and economics. But now a further
portion of the Greek electorate, above all
the young, are signalling they’ve had enough
of corruption and elites.
Greece, though an outlier,
has always been a signifier, too: this is
what happens when modern capitalism fails.
For there are inept bureaucrats and corrupt
elites everywhere: only the trillions of
dollars created and pumped into their
nations’ economies to avoid collapse shields
them from the scrutiny they have received in
Greece.
We face two years of
electoral uncertainty in Europe, with the
far left or the hard right now vying for
power in Spain, France and the Netherlands.
Some are proclaiming this “the end of
neoliberalism”.
I’m not sure of that. All
that’s certain is that Greece shows how it
could end.
Paul Mason
is economics editor at Channel 4 News.
Follow him
@paulmasonnews