Ocean Life Faces Mass
Extinction, Broad Study Says
By Carl Zimmer
January 16, 2015 "ICH"
- "NY
Times"
- A team of scientists, in a groundbreaking
analysis of data from hundreds of sources,
has concluded that humans are on the verge
of causing unprecedented damage to the
oceans and the animals living in them.
“We may be sitting on a
precipice of a major extinction event,” said
Douglas J. McCauley, an ecologist at the
University of California, Santa Barbara, and
an author of the new research, which was
published on Thursday in the journal Science.
But there is still time to
avert catastrophe, Dr. McCauley and his
colleagues also found. Compared with the
continents, the oceans are mostly intact,
still wild enough to bounce back to
ecological health.
“We’re lucky in many ways,”
said Malin L. Pinsky, a marine biologist at
Rutgers University and another author of the
new report. “The impacts are accelerating,
but they’re not so bad we can’t reverse
them.”
Scientific assessments of
the oceans’ health are dogged by
uncertainty: It’s much harder for
researchers to judge the well-being of a
species living underwater, over thousands of
miles, than to track the health of a species
on land. And changes that scientists observe
in particular ocean ecosystems may not
reflect trends across the planet.
Dr. Pinsky, Dr. McCauley and
their colleagues sought a clearer picture of
the oceans’ health by pulling together data
from an enormous range of sources, from
discoveries in the fossil record to
statistics on modern container shipping,
fish catches and seabed mining. While many
of the findings already existed, they had
never been juxtaposed in such a way.
A number of experts said the
result was a remarkable synthesis, along
with a nuanced and encouraging prognosis.
“I see this as a call for
action to close the gap between conservation
on land and in the sea,” said Loren
McClenachan of Colby College, who was not
involved in the study.
There are clear signs already
that humans are harming the oceans to a
remarkable degree, the scientists found.
Some ocean species are certainly
overharvested, but even greater damage
results from large-scale habitat loss, which
is likely to accelerate as technology
advances the human footprint, the scientists
reported.
Coral reefs, for example,
have declined by 40 percent worldwide,
partly as a result of climate-change-driven
warming.
Some fish are migrating to
cooler waters already. Black sea bass, once
most common off the coast of Virginia, have
moved up to New Jersey. Less fortunate
species may not be able to find new ranges.
At the same time, carbon emissions are
altering the chemistry of seawater, making
it more acidic.
“If you cranked up the
aquarium heater and dumped some acid in the
water, your fish would not be very happy,”
Dr. Pinsky said. “In effect, that’s what
we’re doing to the oceans.”
Fragile ecosystems like
mangroves are being replaced by fish farms,
which are projected to provide most of the
fish we consume within 20 years. Bottom
trawlers scraping large nets across the sea
floor have already affected 20 million
square miles of ocean, turning parts of the
continental shelf to rubble. Whales may no
longer be widely hunted, the analysis noted,
but they are now colliding more often as the
number of container ships rises.
Mining operations, too, are
poised to transform the ocean. Contracts for
seabed mining now cover 460,000 square miles
underwater, the researchers found, up from
zero in 2000. Seabed mining has the
potential to tear up unique ecosystems and
introduce pollution into the deep sea.
The oceans are so vast that
their ecosystems may seem impervious to
change. But Dr. McClenachan warned that the
fossil record shows that global disasters
have wrecked the seas before. “Marine
species are not immune to extinction on a
large scale,” she said.
Until now, the seas largely
have been spared the carnage visited on
terrestrial species, the new analysis also
found.
The fossil record indicates
that a number of large animal species became
extinct as humans arrived on continents and
islands. For example, the moa, a giant bird
that once lived on New Zealand,
was wiped out by arriving Polynesians in the
1300s, probably within a century.
But it was only after 1800,
with the Industrial Revolution, that
extinctions on land really accelerated.
Humans began to alter the
habitat that wildlife depended on, wiping
out forests for timber, plowing under
prairie for farmland, and laying down roads
and railroads across continents.
Species began going extinct
at a much faster pace. Over the past five
centuries, researchers have recorded 514
animal extinctions on land. But the authors
of the new study found that documented
extinctions are far rarer in the ocean.
Before 1500, a few species of
seabirds are known to have vanished. Since
then, scientists have documented only 15
ocean extinctions, including animals such as
the Caribbean monk seal and the
Steller’s sea cow.
While these figures are
likely underestimates, Dr. McCauley said
that the difference was nonetheless
revealing.
“Fundamentally, we’re a
terrestrial predator,” he said. “It’s hard
for an ape to drive something in the ocean
extinct.”
Many marine species that have
become extinct or are endangered depend on
land — seabirds that nest on cliffs, for
example, or sea turtles that lay eggs on
beaches.
Still, there is time for
humans to halt the damage, Dr. McCauley
said, with effective programs limiting the
exploitation of the oceans. The tiger may
not be salvageable in the wild — but the
tiger shark may well be, he said.
“There are a lot of tools we
can use,” he said. “We better pick them up
and use them seriously.”
Dr. McCauley and his
colleagues argue that limiting the
industrialization of the oceans to some
regions could allow threatened species to
recover in other ones. “I fervently believe
that our best partner in saving the ocean is
the ocean itself,” said Stephen R. Palumbi
of Stanford University, an author of the new
study.
The scientists also argued
that these reserves had to be designed with
climate change in mind, so that species
escaping high temperatures or low pH would
be able to find refuge.
“It’s creating a hopscotch
pattern up and down the coasts to help these
species adapt,” Dr. Pinsky said.
Ultimately, Dr. Palumbi
warned, slowing extinctions in the oceans
will mean cutting back on carbon emissions,
not just adapting to them.
“If by the end of the century
we’re not off the business-as-usual curve we
are now, I honestly feel there’s not much
hope for normal ecosystems in the ocean,” he
said. “But in the meantime, we do have a
chance to do what we can. We have a couple
decades more than we thought we had, so
let’s please not waste it.”
© 2015 The New York
Times Company
See also -
The heat is on; NOAA,
NASA say 2014 warmest year on record:
For the third time in a decade, the globe
sizzled to the hottest year on record,
federal scientists announced Friday.
Scientists issue
stark warning as Earth passes into ‘danger
zone’:
Human activity over the past century and a
half has pushed the Earth into critical
mode, say scientists. New research published
today finds four out of nine 'planetary
boundaries' have now been crossed.