I
Love Israel - And I Apologize
Apologizing would not solve anything or
atone for anything, but it could signal a
genuine intention to turn a new leaf.
By Gideon Levy
January 04, 2015 "ICH"
- "Haaretz"-
Here comes the new Israeli, a man’s man;
with a tiny skullcap, service in an elite
army unit, high-tech, English and a swimming
pool, with the coolest and most up-to-date
message: “Stop apologizing, we love Israel”
(rhymes in Hebrew); the poster is already in
evidence on several balconies.
On Monday night, at a
meeting convened by Ayelet Shaked (Habayit
Hayehudi), the most successful politician in
Israel at present explained: “This election
is between those who apologize and those who
are proud ... those who are objective and
those who are in favor of the State of
Israel.” Drum roll.
Well, [Habayit Hayehudi
chairman] Naftali Bennett, I apologize and I
love Israel (of course not your Israel and
not the present Israel); I’m objective and
I’m in favor of (a just) State of Israel; I
apologize and I’m proud.
You’re going to stop
apologizing? Israel never even started doing
so. If only it had apologized a long time
ago. If only it would acknowledge its sins,
if only it would accept moral responsibility
for them.
It’s no shame to apologize
– it’s far more embarrassing not to do so.
Apologizing is a strength, not a weakness,
and on the way to reconciliation (with the
Palestinians) we have to stop at the first
station – an apology. It’s true that in the
elite unit of Bennett and Yinon Magal they
don’t apologize for anything, not even for
acts of murder, assassinations and
abductions (the murder of Abu Jihad, for
example, or the abduction of Sheikh Obeid).
In the settlements they don’t apologize for
anything either – not for the exploitation,
not for the disinheritance and not for the
theft.
As a rule, in Israel
people don’t apologize for anything, not in
the occupation nor on the road. Here only
nerds apologize. Guilt feelings are an
embarrassment, and apologizing is for those
with no backbone. That’s why Bennett’s
election slogan: “Stop Apologizing. Be
Proud” will become so catchy and popular:
the “apologizers” vs. “the proud,” the
“objective ones” vs. “lovers of the
country.” I’m proud to belong to the former
group.
I would like to apologize,
if that would be of any significance, to the
entire Palestinian people, throughout the
generations. For 1948, for 1967 and for
everything that happened in their wake. An
apology for 1948 would not have made the
state that was established less just – it
would have become more just. For the mass
expulsion and for preventing the return, for
the ethnic cleansing in several districts
and for several acts of slaughter, which may
be part of every war – we can and should
apologize.
We can and should
apologize for the fact that what happened in
1948 has never ended. That the spirit of
1948 has not passed, and continues to this
very day in the State of Israel’s basic
attitude toward the Palestinian inhabitants
of the land, in its sense of ownership and
superiority, in its aggressiveness and
violence, in its ultranationalism and
racism.
Nor has anything changed
in the policy of dispossession: Take what
you can – then as now, when the State of
Israel is already a regional power. We
should apologize for that. We should
apologize for the innumerable dead killed
for no reason, for the endless lies and
deception. For tyranny in the territories
and for apartheid. For trampling a nation’s
dignity, for suffocating its freedom and for
separating it and breaking it up into tiny
nations. For erasing its heritage and
disdaining its culture. For short-changing
Israeli Arabs and for demonstrations of
racism against them. For the “price tag”
crimes and the Operation Protective Edge
crimes. For all of them we should apologize.
Apologizing would not
solve anything or atone for anything, but it
could signal a genuine intention to turn a
new leaf. Apologizing would broadcast moral
strength and self-confidence, which the
country so badly lacks, convinced as it is
that it can live forever on its sword, even
if there is not a single historical
precedent for that. For all these things
(and more) Israel will have to apologize
some day.
Anyone who believes that
even if the reconciliation is delayed, it
will eventually come, understands that it
must include an apology. That’s how it was
in South Africa and that’s how it will be in
Israel, after the days of the Bennetts, if
it’s not too late.
© Haaretz Daily Newspaper
Ltd. All Rights Reserved