2014: The Year
Propaganda Came Of Age
By Raúl Ilargi Meijer
December 28, 2014 "ICH"
- "The
Automatic Earth" -
From just about as early in my life as I can
remember, growing up as a child in Holland,
there were stories about World War II, and
not just about Anne Frank and the huge
amounts of people who, like her, had been
dragged off to camps in eastern Europe never
to come back, but also about the thousands
who had risked their lives to hide Jewish
and other refugees, and the scores who had
been executed for doing so, often betrayed
by their own neighbors.
And then there were those
who had risked their lives in equally
courageous ways to get news out to people,
putting out newspapers and radio broadcasts
just so there would be a version of events
out there that was real, and not just what
the Germans wanted one to believe. This
happened in all Nazi – and Nazi friendly –
occupied European nations. The courage of
these people is hard to gauge for us today,
and I’m convinced there’s no way to say whom
amongst us would show that kind of bravery
if we were put to the test; I certainly
wouldn’t be sure about myself.
Still, without wanting to
put myself anywhere near the level of those
very very real heroes, please don’t get me
wrong about that, that’s not what I mean, I
was thinking about them with regards to what
is happening in our media today. I’ve
mentioned before that I don’t think Joseph
Goebbels had anything on US and European
media today.
That propaganda as a
strategic and political instrument has been
refined to a huge extent over the past
70-odd years since Goebbels first picked up
on Freud’s lessons on how to influence the
unconscious mind, and the ‘mass-mind’, as a
way to ‘steer’ an entire people, not just as
a means to make them buy detergent. These
days, the media can make people believe just
about anything, and they have the added
benefit that they can pose as friends of the
people, not the enemy.
But there is a reason why
such a large ‘industry’ has developed on the
web with people writing articles that don’t
say what the mass media say. That reason for
is, obviously, first and foremost that not
everybody believes whatever they are told.
The problem is equally obvious: not nearly
enough people are being reached to make a
true difference, and to question the
official narratives.
Me, I have no claim to
fame outside of the appreciation I get from
first, my readers and second, from my
colleagues and peers. I get a lot of both,
and I thank you for that, but this certainly
is not about me. If anything, it’s about
trying to live up to the desire for truth in
the face of odds squarely stacked against
it, and against the people I try to reach
out to. Trying to do just 0.1% of what the
WWII underground press was about.
A few days ago, I wrote in
About That Interview:
The FBI claims
they are certain the hackers are North
Korean, but they have provided no proof
of that claim. We have to trust them on
their beautiful blue eyes. I think
if anything defines 2014 for me,
it’s the advent of incessant claims for
which no proof – apparently – needs to
be provided. Everything related
to Ukraine over the past year carries
that trait. The year of ‘beautiful blue
eyes’, in other words. Never no proof,
you just have to believe what your
government says.
And that truly defines
2014 for me. A level of propaganda I don’t
recognize, and I don’t think I’ve ever seen
before. 2014 has for me been the year of
utter nonsense. To wit, it just finished in
fine form with a 5% US GDP growth number,
just to name one example. Really, guys? 5%?
Really? With all the numbers presented
lately, the negative Thanksgiving sales data
– minus 11% from what I remember -, the
so-so at best Christmas store numbers to
date, shrinking durable goods in November
and all? Plus 5%?
It really doesn’t matter
what I say, does it? You have enough people
believing ridiculous numbers like that to
make it worth your while. After all, that’s
all that counts. It’s a democracy, isn’t it?
If a majority believes something, it becomes
true. If you can get more than 50% of people
to believe whatever you say, that’s case
closed.
With well over 90 million
working age Americans counted as being out
of the labor force, and with 43 million on
food stamps, you can still present a 5% GDP
growth number, if only you can get a
sufficiently large number of people to
‘believe’. And you do, I’ll give you that.
As far as the media goes, we have achieved
the change we can believe in. We may not
have that change, but we sure do believe we
have, don’t we? And isn’t that what counts?
Are congratulations in order?
Well, not where I’m at,
they’re not. I should do a shout out to the
likes of Zero Hedge, Yves Smith, David
Stockman, Wolf Richter, Mish, Steve Keen,
Jim Kunstler, and so many others, we’re a
solid crowd by now even if we’re neglected,
and please don’t feel left out if you’re not
in that list, I know who you are. The
problem is, we’re all completely neglected
by the mass media, even though there are a
ton of very sharp minds in this ‘finance
blogosphere’. And perhaps we should make it
a point to break through that ridiculous
black-out in 2015.
2014, in my eyes, has been
the year of propaganda outdoing even its own
very purpose, and succeeding too. We are
supposed to be living in a time of the best
educated people in the history of mankind,
and everyone thinks (s)he’s mighty smart,
but precious few have even an inkling of a
clue of what transpires in the world they
live in. Talk about a lost generation. Or
two.
We really need to question
the value of higher education, if all we get
for it is a generation of people so easily
duped by utter blubber. What do they teach
people at our universities these days?
Certainly not to think for themselves, that
much is clear. And then what is the use? Why
spend all that time raising an entire
generation of highly educated pawns, sheep
and robots? I can think of some people
liking that, but for society as a whole,
it’s devastating if that’s all higher
education is.
And if you would like to
raise doubts here, the very existence of
finance blogosphere I mentioned before is
proof that we indeed have raised a
generation of sheep. If we had functioning
media, there’d be no need for that
blogosphere. We are the people who keep on
pointing out where the mass media fail, let
alone the politicians, simply by being there
and being supported to the extent we are by
the few people who escape the sheep
mentality.
But that’s not nearly
enough. Journalists, reporters, whatever
they call themselves, working for Bloomberg,
Reuters, CNBC etc. should at the very least
quote Zero Hedge on a daily basis, and Mish,
and Steve, and Yves, and perhaps even me –
though it’s fine if they continue to ignore
me, as long as they give the rest their
rightful place.
There are many people in
the blogosphere who are many times smarter
than the people who write for the mass
media, and that’s a very simple and hardly
disputable fact that needs to be recognized.
When you read something in your paper or at
your online news provider, it should be
second nature to ask yourself: but what
would Tyler Durden say, or the Automatic
Earth, or Naked Capitalism, or David
Stockman?
But we’re nowhere near
that, are we? We’ve been fooled with
economic stats for years, not just in the
US, not even just in the west, but all over,
they all grabbed on to the potential of
providing people with numbers that have
little to do with reality, but that simply
feel good. Or even just look good.
Still, boy, have we been,
and are we being, fooled. Then again, most
of you wouldn’t know, would you? We people
tend to discount the future, to see today as
more important than tomorrow, and in the
same manner we find our children’s future
much less important than our own. Because
that feels good too. If we are comfy right
now, screw them. Not that we’d ever put it
into those terms.
But you know, that’s
really all old hack by now. 2014 brought us
a whole other class of nonsense. And we
swallowed it all hook line and entire
sinker.
2014 gave us Ukraine. And
you just try and find anyone today who
doesn’t think Vladimir Putin is and was the
evil genius mind behind the whole thing,
including the 4500+ people who died there
over the past 10 months. Why is it so hard
to anyone who doubts that narrative? Because
our media told us Putin is the bogeyman. And
‘we’ never asked for any proof. That is,
except for those of us in that same
blogosphere.
Meanwhile, round after
round of sanctions against Russia have been
set up and activated by EU and US, causing
hardship for both Russian people and
European businesses. But why, what exactly
is Putin allegedly guilty of?
The US/EU installed a
government in Kiev in February (yeah, yap
about it), which is still in place, with a
bunch of US citizens recently added for good
measure – and for profit-. The chocolate
prince president was indeed elected months
later, but the prime minister – Yats – was
handpicked by America, and is still
-amazingly – in place. That’s the same
government that had it own army murder
thousands of its own citizens, and not a
thing has been resolved so far.
The whole thing came to a
head when MH17 was shot down over the
summer. That too was blamed on Putin. Or was
it? Well, not directly, nobody said Putin
ordered that plane to be shot. Nor did
anyone say Russia shot it. There is the
accusation that Russian speaking Ukrainian
‘rebels’ did it, but proof for that was
never provided in the 6 months since the
incident. And there must be a best before
date in there somewhere.
Is it possible the
‘rebels’ did it? We can’t exclude it, but
that’s for the same reason we can’t exclude
the option that little green Martians did
it: we don’t know. But even then, even if
they did, there’s the question whether that
would have been on purpose. Which seems
really stretching it: nothing they want
would be served by shooting down a plane
full of European, Malaysian and Australian
holiday goers.
But here we are: no proof
and layer upon layer of sanctions. And nary
a voice is raised in the west. If one is,
it’s to denounce the Russians as
bloodthirsty barbarians. Even though there
is no proof they did anything other than
protecting what they see as their own
people. Something we all would do too, no
questions asked.
Ukraine defines 2014 as
the year western propaganda came into its
own. Not just fictional stories about an
economic recovery anymore, no, we had our
politico-media establishment ram an entire
new cold war down our throats. And we
swallowed it whole. We may have had a
million more years of higher education than
our parents and grandparents, but we sure
don’t seem to have gotten any smarter than
them.
There is a lot of
information out there, written by people
inspired by things other than monetary
incentives or job security or anything like
that, people who simply want to get
information out that your trusted media
won’t give you anymore than Goebbels’ media
did in occupied Europe in the 1940s. And you
don’t even have to risk your lives to access
that information. All you have to do is to
get off your couch.
The Automatic Earth is but
a small part of a very valuable and fast
growing resource that warrants a lot more
attention than it’s been receiving to date.
A reported 5% US GDP growth print is one
reason why, the entire Ukraine fantasy story
is another. The blogosphere is full of
functioning neurons, which is more than you
can say for your papers and online MSM.
As far as media is
concerned, 2014 has been downright scary in
its distortion of reality. Let’s try and
move 2015 a little bit closer towards what’s
actually happening.