By Gideon Levy
July 08, 2022:
Information Clearing House
-- "Haaretz"
----Imagine the
unimaginable: Ilana Dayan (or Yonit Levi)
[both are Israeli journalists & TV
presenters] goes out of her comfort zone in
order to report on the occupation. She is
caught in an exchange of fire and a bullet
hits her in the neck, in the area between
her helmet and her ballistic vest. She dies.
What happens then? Israel very quickly
captures the Palestinian “cell.” It doesn’t
matter who fired, it’s entirely
insignificant, all of its members are killed
or sentenced to life in prison. Israel
mourns the loss of its veteran journalist.
No one even considers forensic tests:
There’s no need for them. It’s clear to
everyone who killed the journalist. The
United States doesn’t think to interfere
with the investigation, only to censure the
Palestinians and participate in the grief of
the Jewish nation, and perhaps also to
impose sanctions on the Palestinian
Authority over the journalist’s murder. It
is obvious to all that the Israeli
journalist was killed because she was Jewish
and because she was a journalist. Her
murderers – that’s what they’ll be called,
of course – intended to murder her. Every
Israeli child will understand this.
But Shireen Abu Akleh was a Palestinian
war correspondent, infinitely more
courageous and determined than Dayan and
Levi put together, and she was killed in
Jenin. Israel washed its hands of any
responsibility, as usual. Washed its hands
and obfuscated. All of the investigations
that have been published so far into the
circumstances of her killing led to a single
conclusion: The Israel Defense Forces shot
her. But Israel continued to obfuscate.
And then came the forensic analysis,
carried out in the presence of a U.S.
military officer. And this is the result:
The U.S. Department of State, which is
concerned about the safety of civilians and
is particularly shocked by harm caused to
journalists, as proved in the Jamal
Khashoggi case, announced that while it is
impossible to determine with certainty who
killed Abu Akleh, the gunfire likely came
from IDF positions. And the punch line: “The
[U.S. Security Coordinator] found no reason
to believe that [the gunfire] was
intentional but rather the result of tragic
circumstances.” The damaged bullet that was
removed from Abu Akleh’s head whispered to
the United States that the shooter didn’t
mean to kill her. It was the most elaborate
ballistic test in history: a test that
examines innermost thoughts, that discerns
intentions.
It’s difficult to imagine a more clumsy,
unprofessional, ridiculous and even
insulting mobilization in the service of
Israeli propaganda. Once again it has been
proven that America is willing to do
anything, absolutely anything, to protect
its precious darling; to conceal all its
crimes, to make itself an object of
ridicule, to disregard moral, legal and
professional standards – all to cover up for
Israel. America is telling Israel: Keep on
killing journalists, as far as we’re
concerned it’s fine. We will always say you
didn’t mean to, that tragic circumstances
killed Abu Akleh and not soldiers in the
Duvdevan counter-terrorism unit.
Americans also don’t watch CNN. The
network’s investigation disclosed that three
or four additional bullet holes can be seen
on the tree Abu Akleh was standing against
when she was hit – bullets that were fired
individually, not in a burst. Does this also
indicate that there was no intention to kill
the journalist, who took cover under the
tree?
Could it be that it’s possible to mute,
obscure and deceive so much for the sole
purpose of making President Joe Biden’s
upcoming visit to Israel more pleasant? Does
the U.S. consider covering up for a crime an
expression of friendship toward its
perpetrator?
“Who killed Norma Jean?” Pete Seeger
asked in the wonderful song he composed of
Norman Rosten’s poem. “Who saw her die / I,
said the Night, and a bedroom light, we saw
her die. … Who’ll bear the pall? / We, said
the Press, in pain and distress, / We’ll
bear the pall. / Who’ll soon forget? / I,
said the Page, beginning to fade, / I’ll be
the first to forget.”
Abu Akleh is dead, and with her the last
remnants of trusting the United States to
tell the truth about its ally. Thanks to it,
Israel can continue to claim that we’ll
never know who killed Shireen. But it seems
that we know very well who killed her. He
walks among us now.
America is telling Israel: Keep on
killing journalists, as far as we’re
concerned it’s fine. We will always say you
didn’t mean to.