Capitalism is one virus away from existential
disaster
By George Galloway
March 18, 2020 "Information
Clearing House" - Franklin D.
Roosevelt and John Maynard Keynes have been
knocked into a cocked hat by Donald Trump, Boris
Johnson, and Emmanuel Macron, the new holy
trinity of dirigiste capitalism.
According to the laws of capitalist
economics, an airline which cannot fill its
seats must go to the wall. If the public's taste
for ocean-going cruises dissipates either by
fashion or pandemic, the cruise company goes
under the relentless waves, sink or swim.
John Maynard Keynes and Franklin D. Roosevelt
bucked that in the 1930s Great Depression,
deciding that the fate of nations could not be
left merely to the unseen hand of market forces,
but that if not a heart then at least a brain
must be applied. That accountancy was not
economics.
The descendants of Keynes and FDR would not
normally be found in either the British Conservative
Party or the GOP. Reagan and Thatcher must be
turning in their graves. Because this week the
prevailing capitalist orthodoxy was turned on its
head and eye-watering sums of public money were
splashed not by Sanders or Corbyn or Melenchon, but
by their polar opposites whose whole careers have
been built on denouncing the slightest bit of
Keynesianism as socialism or even communism.
Unless one believes all three have experienced a
Damascene conversion, one can safely say the scale
of the bail-out equals the scale of the threat
perceived to capitalism itself by the coronavirus
epidemic. Donald Trump is getting ready to sign
$1,000
checks to “every American.” Macron,
under siege and thinking of the Bastille every
morning he wakes up, is going to spend the
equivalent of 20 percent of France's 2019 GDP to
beat this new unseen, elusive enemy.
When the pigs in Animal Farm metamorphosed into
the opposite of their former selves, they began to
chant “four legs good, two legs better.”
For the Holy Trinity, equality was always good, but
some would be more equal than others. “Public
good, private better” was their mantra.
But the scale of the public health threat posed
by the pandemic demonstrates beyond contradiction
that private is not better than public, an economy
which principally is private cannot meet the needs
of the human race when existential dangers arrive.
This is not new, though it may have been
forgotten.