There's a reason, Tim Bakken says, why the U.S.
hasn't won a war in 75 years.
By Kelley
Beaucar Vlahos
February 17, 2020 "Information
Clearing House" -
What do you call a
civilian law professor who, after successfully
filing for federal whistleblower status to keep his
job teaching at West Point Military Academy,
proceeds to write a bombshell book about the
systematic corruption, violence, fraud, and
anti-intellectualism he says has been rampant at the
historic institution for over a hundred years?
Well, if you are
part of the military leadership or an alumnus of the
storied military academy, you may call him a
traitor.
But if you are
anyone searching for reasons why the most powerful
military in the world has not won a war in 75 years,
you might call him a truth-teller. And a pretty
brave one at that.
Tim Bakken’s
The Cost of
Loyalty: Dishonesty, Hubris and Failure in the U.S.
Military
is set for release tomorrow, and it should land like
a grenade. Unlike the myriad critiques of the
military that wash over the institution from outside
the Blob, this one is written by a professor with 20
years on the inside. He knows the instructors, the
culture, the admissions process, the scandals, the
cover-ups, and how its legendary “warrior-scholars”
have performed after graduation and on the
battlefield.
Bakken’s
prognosis: the military as an institution has become
so separate, so insulated, so authoritarian, that it
can no longer perform effectively. In fact, it’s
worse: the very nature of this beast is that it has
been able to grow exponentially in size and mission
so that it now conducts destructive expeditionary
wars overseas with little or no real cohesive
strategy or oversight. Its huge budgets are a source
of corporate grift, self-justification, and
corruption. The military has become too big, yes,
but as Bakkan puts it, it’s failing in every way
possible.
In addition to
losing wars, “the military’s loyalty to itself and
determined separation from society have produced an
authoritarian institution that is contributing to
the erosion of American democracy,” writes Bakkan,
who is still, we emphasize, teaching at the school.
“The hubris, arrogance, and self-righteousness of
officers have isolated the military from modern
thinking and mores. As a result, the military
operates in an intellectual fog, relying on
philosophy and practices that literally originated
at West Point two hundred years ago.”