By Craig Murray
February 03, 2020 "Information
Clearing House" - I have
read through the
entire 181 pages of Trump’s “peace deal” for
Israel, and it is breathtaking. It is not just that
the “solution” it proposes is ludicrously one-sided,
it is the entire analysis of the problem to be
solved which reads as pure, unadulterated zionist
propaganda.
For example, the word “violence” is used
repeatedly. But it only ever refers to violence by
Arabs. There is not one single mention of violence
by Israel against the Palestinians, even though the
ratio of killing between Israelis and Palestinians
over the last ten years is approximately 80:1 . The
only mention of violence against Palestinians at all
relates to Kuwaiti expulsion of Palestinian refugees
after the first Gulf war.
The analysis of the refugee issue is the same.
Nowhere can the paper bring itself to note the key
historic fact, that the Palestinian refugees were
expelled from Israel. The paper treats Palestinian
refugees as if they had simply materialised as an
inconvenient phenomenon, like a plague of locusts.
This “othering” of Palestinian refugees permeates
the entire paper:
It must be stressed that many Palestinian
refugees in the Middle East come from war torn
countries, such as Syria and Lebanon that are
extremely hostile toward the State of Israel
No. Palestinian refugees were driven by violence
from the land that is now Israel. Families who lived
there two generations ago have been displaced in
favour of families who claim the land because their
ancestors lived there eighty generations ago. That
is a matter of indisputable fact.
You can claim that displacement of the
Palestinians from Israel was justifiable because of
the urgent need for a state for Jewish people after
the Holocaust. You can claim that the displacement
of Palestinians from Israel is justifiable because
it is divinely ordained. You can claim the
displacement of Palestinians from Israel is
regrettable but irreversible. Make what argument you
wish, but to refuse to acknowledge the basic fact
that the Palestinian refugees were driven from
Israel is a pathetic act of cowardice that
underlines the sheer intellectual shoddiness of the
paper.