By Charles Hugh Smith
August
21, 2017 "Information
Clearing House"
- Remember the "Russians hacked our
election!" hysteria--or have you already
forgotten? That entire narrative collapsed
under a deluge of factual evidence that the
Democratic National Committee (DNC) data release
was an insider job, and a compelling lack of
evidence of any other Russian hacking.
That failed narrative has now been
replaced with a new mass hysteria: "a new
cultural Civil War is inevitable." In this
narrative, America has succumbed to
us-versus-them divisions divided by
all-or-nothing ideological bright lines.
Snap out of it, America: you're being
played, just as you were played by the
absurd "Russia hacked the election" mania.
The core strategy here is the destruction
of any common ground: once the delusion that
there is no common ground left has been cemented
by relentless mainstream and social media
hysteria/ propaganda, the populace fragments
into echo-chamber fiefdoms of ideological
conformity that are easily manipulated by the
political-financial power structure.
Once the populace has been fragmented into
ideologically divisive camps, controlling the
resulting mass of warring mobs is easy.
Rather than recognize the commonality of their
powerlessness and impoverishment, the fragmented
fiefdoms are easily turned on each other:
From the point of view of each fragmented
fiefdom, the problem isn't structural, i.e. the
dominance of extreme concentrations of wealth
and power; the "problem" is the other
cultural-ideological fiefdoms.
Once the masses accept this false division
and the destruction of common ground, their
power to reverse the extreme concentrations of
wealth and power is shattered. The play is
as old as civilization itself: conjure up
extremists (paying them when necessary), goad
the formation of opposing extremists, then
convince the populace that these extremists have
been normalized, i.e. your friends and
neighbors already belong to one or the other.
This normalization then sets up the
relentless demands to choose a side-- the
classic techniques of misdirection and
false choice.
Just as you're sold a triple-bacon
cheeseburger or a hybrid auto, you're being sold
a completely fabricated cultural civil war.
There have always been extremists on every edge
of the ideological spectrum, just as there have
always been religious zealots.
In a healthy society, these fringe pools of
self-reinforcing fanaticism are given their
proper place: they are outliers, representing
self-reinforcing black holes of confirmation
bias of a few.
In times of social, political and financial
stress, such groups pop up like mushrooms. In
times of media saturation, a relative handful
can gain enormous exposure and importance
because the danger they pose sells adverts and
attracts eyeballs/viewers.
Add a little fragmentation,
virtue-signaling, demands for ideological
conformity and voila, you get a deeply
fragmented and deranged populace that is
incapable of recognizing the dire straits it is
in or recognizing the structural sources of its
impoverishment and powerlessness.
In other words, you get an easily mallable
populace at false war with itself.
There is always common ground for those
who dare to seek it. The Powers That Be are
blowing up the bridges as fast as they can,
whipping up fear and hatred of the Other,
fanning the flames of extremism and claiming
extremists are now normalized and everywhere.
All of this is false. Would you buy an
entirely manipulated cultural civil war if it
was advertised as such? If not, then don't buy
into the false (but oh so useful to the ruling
elites) narrative of an "inevitable cultural
Civil War."
Charles Hugh Smith is a contributing editor to