In the Time of
Trump, All We Have Is Each Other
By Chris Hedges
December 26,
2016 "Information
Clearing House"
- "Truth
Dig" -
This Christmas I
mourn the long, slow death of our democracy that led to
the political ascendancy of Donald Trump. I fear the
euphoria of those who have embraced the atavistic lust
for violence and bigotry stoked by him. These nativist
forces, part of the continuum of white vigilante
violence directed against people of color and radical
dissidents throughout American history, are once again
being groomed as instruments of mass intimidation and
perhaps terror. I know that our civil and political
institutions, poisoned by neoliberalism and captured by
the corporate state, have neither the will nor the
ability to protect us. We are on our own. It won’t be
pleasant.
A week ago in
New York I
spoke with Ellen Schrecker, the country’s foremost
historian of McCarthyism and the author of “Many
Are the Crimes: McCarthyism in America,” “No
Ivory Tower: McCarthyism & The Universities” and “The
Lost Soul of Higher Education: Corporatization, the
Assault on Academic Freedom, and the End of the American
University.”
“What am I
seeing?” she asked about the nation’s political and
cultural condition. “Am I seeing a replay of the
McCarthy era? To a large extent some of the parallels
are stunning. You can look at a figure like
[Sen. Joseph] McCarthy, who symbolized a much
broader repressive movement. I would say Trump plays the
same role today for what really is a right-wing
reactionary movement that has taken over the American
government.”
“There are a
number of fairly superficial comparisons we can make,”
Schrecker went on. “I think both McCarthy and Trump are
somewhat abhorrent characters—perhaps there’s a little
sociopath involved there. McCarthy was a genius at
working the press. He understood how to get himself on
the front pages. He knew the deadlines that specific
reporters had. He knew how to feed them stories. I think
the parallels there are pretty obvious. Trump is a
genius with regard to the media.”
The Wisconsin
senator was, as Trump is now, very opportunistic, she
said. McCarthy, a Democrat before he became a
Republican, “was just a little bit late” in exploiting
the
Red Scare, Schrecker said, latching on to it in
1950, “by which time the
Un-American Activities Committee had been hounding
Hollywood.”
Trump and his
Christian fascist minions, sooner than most of us
expect, will seek to shut down the small spaces left for
free expression. Dissent will become difficult and
sometimes dangerous. There will be an overt campaign of
discrimination and hate crimes directed against a host
of internal enemies, including undocumented workers,
Muslims, African-Americans and dissidents. The Christian
right will be given a license to roll back women’s
rights, insert their
magical thinking into school curriculums and
terrorize Muslims and the GBLT community. The Trump
administration will hand our Christian jihadists a
platform to champion a repugnant religious chauvinism
that fuses the symbols and language of the Christian
religion with American capitalism, imperialism and white
supremacy.
Repressive
measures, I expect, will be implemented swiftly. Speed
blinds a captive population to what is happening.
Already anemic democratic traditions and institutions,
including the legal system, the two major political
parties and the press, will crumble under the assault.
Trump will use the familiar tools that make possible the
authoritarian state: mass incarceration, militarized
police, crippling of the judicial system, demonization
of opponents real and imagined, and obliteration of
privacy and civil liberties, all foolishly promoted by
the political elites on behalf of corporate power.
Schrecker said
the rise of Trump has been in the making for four
decades. Corporations funded and established
institutions to close the cultural, social and political
openings made in the 1960s, especially in universities,
the press, labor and the arts. These corporate forces
turned government into a destructive power. America was
pillaged and cannibalized for profit. We now live in a
deindustrialized wasteland. This scorched-earth assault
created fertile ground for a demagogue.
The late Lewis
Powell, a general counsel to the U.S. Chamber of
Commerce and later a Supreme Court justice, in 1971
wrote
an eight-page memo outlining a campaign to counter
what the document’s title described as an “Attack on
American Free Enterprise System.” The memo established
the
Business Roundtable, which generated huge monetary
resources and political clout to direct government
policy and mold public opinion. The Powell report listed
methods that corporations could use to silence those in
“the college campus, the pulpit, the media, the
intellectual and literary journals” who were hostile to
corporate interests.
Powell called
for the establishment of lavishly funded think tanks and
conservative institutes. He proposed that ideological
assaults against government regulation and environmental
protection be directed at a mass audience. He advocated
placing corporate-friendly academics and neoliberal
economists in universities and banishing from the public
sphere those who challenged unfettered corporate
power—especially Ralph Nader, whom Powell cited by name.
Organizations were to be formed to monitor and pressure
the media to report favorably on issues that furthered
corporate interests. Pro-corporate judges were to be
placed on the bench.
Academics were
to be controlled by pressure from right-wing watch
lists, co-opted university administrators and wealthy
donors. Under the prolonged assault the universities,
like the press, eventually became compliant, banal and
monochromatic.
“He spelled out
a need for an alternative to academic knowledge,”
Schrecker said of Powell. “He felt the academy had been
undermined by the left. He wanted to establish an
alternative source of expertise. What you’re getting in
the 1970s is the development of things like the American
Enterprise Institute [in existence since 1938] , The
Heritage Foundation, a whole bunch of think tanks on the
right who people in the media can go to and get
expertise. But it’s politically motivated.”
“It was
unbelievably successful,” she said of the campaign.
“It’s pretty bad. What we’re seeing today is an assault
on knowledge. What came out of this are the culture wars
of the late 1980s and 1990s which created a set of
stereotypes of professors as deconstructionist, raging
feminists who hate men, cross-dressers, and, worse, who
are out of touch with reality.”
The ideological
attack was accompanied by corporate campaigns to defund
public schools and universities, along with public
broadcasting and the arts. The humanities were
eviscerated. Vocational training, including the
expansion of the study of finance and economics in
universities, replaced disciplines that provided
students with cultural and historical literacy, that
allowed them to step outside of themselves to feel and
express empathy for the other. Students were no longer
taught how to think, but what to think. Civic education
died. A grotesque kind of illiteracy—one exemplified by
Trump—was celebrated. Success became solely about
amassing wealth. The cult of the self, the essence of
corporatism, became paramount.
Schrecker said
that during the McCarthy era most of the Red baiting,
blacklisting and censorship emanated from the
government, especially J. Edgar Hoover’s Federal Bureau
of Investigation. Hoover and McCarthy, along with
Richard Nixon and Roy Cohn, left ruined lives and
reputations in the wake of their vicious inquisitions.
They effectively shut down freedom of speech and freedom
of thought. Cohn, who was a prosecutor in the espionage
case that sent
Julius and Ethel Rosenberg to the electric chair,
was later
Trump’s lawyer and close friend for 13 years. Cohn
was disbarred in 1986, shortly before his death, for
what a court called unethical, unprofessional and
“particularly reprehensible” conduct.
“There are …
many more private entities” involved in today’s
anti-democratic campaign, Schrecker said. “It’s a bit of
everything. That’s why it’s so dangerous. It’s not just
Trump. Trump is clearly about to become very powerful.
Nonetheless, there have been these forces, the climate
deniers, the oil people, all of them are coming together
at this particular point in time.”
We must begin
again. Any hope for a restoration of civil society will
come from small, local groups and community
organizations. They will begin with the mundane tasks of
holding back the expansion of charter schools, enforcing
environmental regulations, building farmers markets,
fighting for the minimum wage, giving sanctuary to
undocumented workers, protesting hate crimes and
electing people to local offices who will seek to
mitigate the excesses of the state.
“We have to
reconstitute a civil society,” Schrecker said.
“Intermediary institutions like the academy and the
media have been hollowed out. Certainly, journalism is
on life support. We have to resuscitate organizations
and institutions that have atrophied.”
“There is an
attack on the American mind,” she said. “A lot of what
we’re seeing with Trump is the product of 40 years of
dumbing down.”
A crisis is
traditionally used by authoritarian and totalitarian
regimes to put a country in lockdown. An economic
meltdown, a large domestic terrorist attack, widespread
devastation from climate change or the orchestrated
escalation of hostilities with another country, perhaps
Iran or China, will see Trump and his rogue generals,
billionaires and conspiracy theorists plunge the United
States into dystopia.
War is the
usual vehicle that demagogues use to justify internal
repression and wield unchallenged power. If the federal
government expands our wars to create new enemies, even
local resistance will be impermissible. All dissent will
be criminalized. Institutions, fearful and weak, will
carry out purges of those few who speak out. Most of
society, intimidated by a war psychosis, will be
compliant to avoid being targeted. Resistance will often
be tantamount to suicide.
The late
Rev. Daniel Berrigan declared in a
2008 conversation with me that the American empire
was in irrevocable decline. He said that in the face of
this dissolution we must hold fast to the non-historical
values of compassion, simplicity, love and justice. The
rise and fall of civilizations, he noted, is part of the
cyclical nature of history.
“The tragedy
across the globe is that we are pulling down so many
others,” he said. “We are not falling gracefully. Many,
many people are paying with their lives for this.”
We must not
become preoccupied with the short-term effects of
resistance. Failure is inevitable for many of us.
Tyrants have silenced voices of conscience in the past.
They will do so again. We will endure by holding fast to
our integrity, by building community and by spawning new
institutions in the midst of the wreckage. We will
sustain each other. Perhaps enough of us will endure to
begin again.
Chris
Hedges, spent nearly two decades as a foreign
correspondent in Central America, the Middle East,
Africa and the Balkans. He has reported from more than
50 countries and has worked for The Christian Science
Monitor, National Public Radio, The Dallas Morning News
and The New York Times, for which he was a foreign
correspondent for 15 years.
Robert Reich: Trump’s Attack on
the Freedom of the Press Op-ed - (Video):
Historically, tyrants have tried to control the press
using 4 techniques that, worryingly, Donald Trump is
already using.
The views
expressed in this article are the author's own and do
not necessarily reflect Information Clearing House
editorial policy. |